Back in January, THP held its 2010 Driver Shoot Out with many of the worlds best new drivers that were coming out over the course of the year. When all the smoke cleared, the 2010 Callaway Diablo Edge driver was declared the winner. Throughout the entire event, all of the testers remarked at how much they were enjoying the driver overall and it had us salivating as we wanted more. Once that Shoot Out was complete THP quickly contacted Callaway Golf, because we were eager to try out the rest of the Diablo Edge line of clubs. Upon arrival, our THP testers immediately went to work to find out if the irons and hybrids would live up to the driver that won us all over.
Technical Information
The Diablo Edge irons are engineered for distance and accuracy. Designed with a lower, deeper center of gravity, Diablo Edge Irons feature a more accessible sweet spot that is in line with where most amateurs commonly hit the ball on the clubface. The result is longer, consistent distance and improved accuracy. The Solid Impact Sole delivers smooth turf interaction and is designed to mitigate the effects of heavy and thin shots. It also improves the impact location on the face for greater distance.
“In designing the new Diablo Edge Irons, we’ve taken our proven technologies and combined them with insight on where average golfers make contact on the club face, then moved the sweet spot accordingly,” said Dr. Alan Hocknell, Senior Vice President of Research & Development, Callaway Golf. “The result of that effort is greater distance overall and greater distance consistency.”
The new product introduction retail price is $599 for a steel-shafted set. The Diablo Edge Irons are also available in combo sets, which feature six irons and two Diablo Edge Hybrids. The combo set with two graphite-shafted hybrids and six steel-shafted irons has a new product introduction retail price of $699. The combo set with two graphite-shafted hybrids and six graphite-shafted irons has a new product introduction retail price of $799. The addition of hybrids to the set greatly benefits players who struggle with hitting their long irons and provides them with greater distance through the entire bag.
For the purposes of this review, THP is covering the combo set of 3 & 4 hybrids and 5-PW in irons.
Iron Shafts – Callaway Diablo Uniflex
Hybrid Shafts – Graphite Stiff
Looks
The irons have strong, sharp lines that draw you right in. Most will either love or hate the looks, and I am one that really likes the way they look quite a bit. The splashes of deep red sparkle in the sun as the bag is on the course and the tiny little diablo emblems in the cavity add to the depth even more. The sole is slightly thick, but no more than most game improvement (GI) irons and has a large number for identifying purposes on it. The topline of the club matches that of the sole and has a sandblasted type of look to it that works well in keeping the sun from producing blinding light off of the chrome.
The hybrids match the set so perfectly it was as if the marriage was there from the beginning. The sole of the club has the same large numbers and sharp lines as the cavity in the iron. It is filled with the deep red color that will make it “pop” in the sun. The crown of the hybrid is two tone, with the face being a different color and coming up on the top of the club. The overall shape is definitely more hybrid than fairway wood and we were glad that they went that way in the design process. Though, it comes down to personal preference of course. The headcover of the hybrid is more old school, than new school and will get polarizing opinions. Im not a huge fan of it overall, but that is more about the style than the look. Overall, myself and the rest of testers really liked the look of the set quite a bit and they begged to be taken to the course.
Range Testing
THP was able to gather up 12 testers to try both the hybrids and irons on the range. Each golfer is given a scorecard and asked to “score” the clubs on Looks, Feel, Distance, Accuracy, and Overall. None of these golfers are affiliated with THP or Callaway Golf in anyway. Here are their scores.
Looks – 7.5/10 – Overall the players really liked the looks of the clubs. One suggestion that we found we really liked was that the hybrid shaft should have been red. That would have really made the club stand out. No major complaints about the looks of the irons other than a few thought they were “busy” looking.
Feel – 7.0/10 – No real complaints about the feel either. A few thought the feel at impact was a little muted in the feedback area compared to that of some other irons, but overall, the feel was well liked.
Distance – 10/10 – The golfers were almost astonished at the distances they were achieving with the irons. In some cases a full club more than their normal distances. The hybrids provided left no gap either, meaning that the hybrid/iron set was perfect. Golfers were literally grinning when hitting these clubs and watching them fly.
Accuracy – 9/10 – The irons by themselves would have received a full 10 out of 10 because the old saying of “high and straight” is exactly what they were seeing. The hybrids were great as well on the accuracy side, but one of the golfers struggled a touch with hooking them too much.
Overall – The testers came away from this set absolutely raving about them. Distance and accuracy is what most want in their clubs and these delivered in so many ways.
Positive – The testers absolutely could not get over the distance they were getting out of these.
Negative – Almost unanimously the players did not like the stock grips.
Course Testing
After watching the range testing take place, I was personally eager to bring these out on the course in my bag. I loaded up the entire set and without ever trying them other than warmups went out to the course. Within the first few holes, I realized that I had a problem. I had to readjust my distances because the testers were right, these are LONG! So long, that I flew over the green on the 1st 5 holes on approach shots even after going down a club. After the first round I did not know if I should be upset with the score I posted, or excited about the prospect of playing the next day…I went with the latter.
The next day we played 36 holes and after starting slow again, I really found my groove with these irons. Being able to hit an 8 iron rather than a 7 can make every golfer’s life just a little easier. More than just the distance, what I found was a nice high ball flight that was slightly penetrating and the ball just soar in the air. The forgiveness that the Callaway Diablo Edge irons offer is flat out fantastic. When missing the ball off the toe, you notice almost no difference in the ball flight and very little distance loss either. Something we rarely see, and was quite exciting. Another area where the forgiveness really shined was when hitting the ball a little high on the club face. While the feel is slightly muted, the ball had no distance loss it seemed at all.
The big question we will find with this iron set is can the ball be “worked” right and left. The short answer is yes, and without much a problem. Like most GI irons, they are built to go high and straight, and the Callaway Diablo Edge irons did that better than most. But playing a cut or a small draw did not seem to be much a problem either. The offset that the irons have, especially in the 5 & 6 iron made it slightly harder to pull off, but in the end, these clubs are built to go straight and they do it well.
Similar to the testers, one thing I really liked about the set was the integration and lack of distance gap when using the hybrids. Many times when adding hybrids to a set, you end up with a pretty big distance gap in between where your irons start and your hybrids end. The Diablo Edge set did not have that problem at all, in fact due to the distance I was getting out of the irons, you could in fact drop another one and add a 3rd hybrid if you really struggle with long irons. The hybrids are extremely easy to hit and are ultra forgiving. One little note though, if you struggle with a hook, these hybrids may in fact bring that out every now and then. It definitely feels as though the weighting and offset are geared to keep it straight or help with a fade.
After 9 rounds of golf and countless range sessions I have come to some conclusions about this set and most are really good.
* Flat out one of the longest set of irons I have ever tried and reviewed on THP.
* Unreal amount of forgiveness to assist golfers in keeping it straight.
* Solid feel and feedback, especially when considering how forgiving they are.
* The grips, as the testers pointed out, are not great in my opinion.
* Did I mention how great these irons are in the distance category?
Overall
Callaway has a set in the Diablo Edge that is absolutely fantastic on many levels. Distance and accuracy is what can help drive scoring and if you struggle with either one, this set should be on your short list. The irons offer a good feel for a GI iron and provide flat out amazing forgiveness. The hybrids offer great distance and solid forgiveness as well. After testing these out for the last month, I am thoroughly convinced that this set will help quite a bit of golfers take their game to the next level. For more information on these or any other Callaway Golf products, check out their website at www.callawaygolf.com.
Till Next Time
Josh B.
Great review JB,I think I just made up my mind….finally…on which set of irons to buy.
I got this set about 2 weeks ago and absolutely love them. I tried out about 9 other sets and this one fit me the best. Since that time, I have dropped my scores by 2 strokes a round (3 rounds) and am finally dialing them in. Your review was spot on with the distance and forgiveness.
The distance is really intriguing here. I have been thinking about this set for a few months now and am glad that it has the forgiveness that it claims. I have been playing x-18s for a while now, but might be looking to upgrade here.
I think what’s most astonishing about these is the price tag. They seem to be very affordable if one went with steel shafts in their irons. I think price alone will put these sticks in a lot of golfer’s bags.
Nice write up JB, any chance you’ll be getting your hands on the forged version?
TC,
We will put in our request for them and see if Callaway would like us to review them as well.
Stellar review and love that it seems to be one of the only places to get a review where this many people try the stuff. Would love to know how to become a tester. HA
Since you posted the pictures I have been waiting for this review. It confirmed my thoughts after trying them at Golf Galaxy. These clubs are that good, before I buy them, I am hoping to see your thoughts on the forged set as well. Thanks THP.
Something that might need to be added to this and future reviews is the standard specs of the clubs. It is all distance, distance, distance. I think many people don’t realize that these clubs (and others like the TM Burner) have much stronger lofts. I checked the specs and these are 3 degrees stronger than most standard lofts. Of course they will go further. I guess if that makes people feel better to hit these further than their regular clubs more power to them. They are just kidding themselves though. A club will not instantly make someone hit a ball further. Maybe a little, but the extra 3 degrees is the biggest factor. Sure the 9-iron will go further, but it is not the same 9-iron.
The clubs might go further, but I would bet that loft for loft, they won’t be much different than anything else.
Joe,
That is a good point, but not the only reason, in my opinion. Metal technology, weighting, etc.. all play into the role as does length. However there is one remaining fact and that is that the irons do go farther. If a company chooses to go strong lofted, that is a preference that golfers can decide on what works best for them. Other companies choose more traditional lofts. It will be up to the individual user to find out what works best for them. And the stronger lofts did not change the forgiveness at all, and these just rock in that area.
Great review JB thanks to you and the other testers. I would love to see a review of the forged version. It does not seem to be getting the same amount of press as the Edge does.
Since these clubs are a full club longer than your own clubs did that leave a distance gap between the diablo pitching wedge and your gap wedge?
Bill,
That is a great question. It did for my 1st round, but I adjusted by switching out to a 50* wedge rather than my normal 52*.
Specs are pretty standard these days. Only 2* stronger than the 2002 Big Berthas, and pretty much identical to the Adams AxOS series.
Interesting bit is that the specs for the hybrids in the ‘combo set’ are different from the hybrids sold individually. The 3 and 4 Irons are 19* and 22*, but the hybrids are listed as 21* and 24* @ 39.75″ and 39″, vs. the individual hybrids on the diablo spec page at 40.5″ and 39.5″ for 21* and 24*.
Going from 24*, 39″ 4H to 25*,38.5″ is probably why there isn’t much of a hybrid-iron gap.
Nice review JB. I think that Callaway has found a good successor to its Big Bertha line. Long and straight is always good.
I too would like to see the forged irons reviewed.
Great review, JB.
If you would compare this set with the Cleveland CG7 Black Pearl set you reviewed earlier, what set would you prefer to play?
birdie,
That is a great question. I am not sure I can answer it because I do not have the CG7 BPs here anymore to do a side by side. They are BOTH AWESOME sets and will come down to budget, looks, and personal feel. But let me see if I can do my best.
Looks – CG7 BP’s – Possibly the best I have seen
Feel – CG7 BP’s – Solid feel for a GI
Distance – Diablo Edge – A full club longer
Accuracy – Tie
Forgiveness – Diablo Edge – But Barely.
Hopefully this helps. You really cannot go wrong with either set.
I’ve never met a “uniflex” shaft that I liked. Why uniflex? I don’t get it!!!
That is what a company chooses to send when they are going to have upwards of 15 trying out one set of clubs.
On distance, yes simply calling a 2 lofted club a 3 iron or an 8 lofted club a 9 iron does not make it a longer club. Of course most of the manufacturers are doing it versus older loft/club designations. Versus the modern Ping G15 irons, the lofts of the Diablo Edge irons are only 1 degree stronger 3-6, the same loft 7-PW, and varies within 1* in the remaining wedges.
Is anyone else bothered by the way Calloway paints the bottom 2 grooves white? I know its trivial but it’s actually something that has kept me from ever considering one of their iron sets, you never want to be annoyed at your club when you’re standing over the ball.
I really like it actually. It adds extra framing. But in reality, you cannot see it at setup anyway. The ball is there and the paint in grooves does not last too long.
How did these compare to the r9s in terms of accuracy and forgiveness and feel
Seth,
They are very different irons. Forgiveness wise, I would give the edge to the Edge. Accuracy wise, it would depend on what you are trying to do. High and straight, then these would get the edge. If you want to work the ball left and right or hit some lower shots, the easier iron to do that with would be the R9. The closer comparison would be the Edge irons and the Burner irons.
I didn’t see this review when it came out, I had other things going on. I love these irons! Could do without the line across the front of the hybrid but could live with it.
If the only negative thing is the grips and possibly the shafts, which grips and shaft combo would you recomend?
Tony,
I did not have any issues with the shafts and like them quite a bit with these heads. As for what grips, it is totally a personal preference. It will really come down to what is comfortable in your hands.
Lots of good information there. Thanks for sharing that. Can’t wait till the game comes out. There are similar discussions going on, if ya wanna discuss some things about the upcoming Diablo 3 beta check the diablo 3 forums at http://www.d3owned.com
What are you talking about? Thats a video game! Wrong site!
TonyB,
You are right, just the typical spammer.
Thanks for all the great input. I have a question if you don’t mind: I’m looking to purchase some irons and am currently between the x-22’s and the diablo edge irons. I score in the low / mid 90’s and am looking for a forgiving iron that will help me improve my game. i was at a national retailer this weekend and the salesperson was really pushing the diablo edge irons (rather than the x-22’s). thoughts?
Great Review. Looking at many sets of Irons right now. Time to upgrade my Cobra S9s from 3 yrs ago. Currently looking at the Calloway Diablo series, TM R9s, TM Burners, Ping I & G 15s. This brings me to the real question. When is THP doing their Irons Shoot Out so I can read an unbiased review on the new irons out, rather than trying to sort through the advertising biased reviews from Golf Digest?
I’m in the same boat as UConn with the x-22 or Diablo Edge choice. Anyone have any good input on differences/similarities? I was at a local Golf Town the past couple days, most of the guys in there just preached personal feel as the main difference. Anyone help with some more input? Thanks.
Oh and GJ on the review Josh. I’m a newbie to Hackersparadise but I’ve quickly seen the high quality of your posts. And most importantly, they are relevant to the average golfer.
Adam,
In my opinion, the X-22s offer a little more workability and a little less forgiveness and distance.
Thanks for the quick response 🙂
I guess I am not as concerned with workability vs. forgiveness and distance. I’m a 10-15 handicap and my swing is less than consistant… I may work the ball sometimes but it is usually not by choice lol.
I’m planning on playing quite abit more this year and have my eyes on the Edges. I was wondering though, if my game improves exponentially (unlikely but still) this year… is there any concern about outgrowing these clubs in favor of a less forgiving/workable counterpart? I guess this can be concidered a broader question on the playability of GI’s over long periods.
Thanks for any help you can give 🙂
Adam,
That is something we hear a lot, and I just do not see it. I have been playing this game for 20 years and have played just about every iron type out there. This year I went back to GI irons and have been hitting the ball better than ever before. My GHIN is just over 5 and it is going down since the switch.
Thanks for this great review. I have almost make up my mind after reading it through.
However, I still would want to find out how does this iron set compared to R9 Max? Would there be any reviews with R9 Max?
I am currently torn between Edge and R9 Max … how i am swinging towards Edge after your review.
thanks. 😀
TF,
The R9 Max is a Japan only model club. We do not review irons such as those on the site. We try to only review clubs that people will have the opportunity to try and buy. Thanks.
Thanks JB, how about a comparison between R9 and Edge? 😀
Very different. I would compare these more to the Burners in terms of playability.
How would you compare the TM Burner Super Launch to the diablo edge irons?
Like some others I am looking forward to hearing the comparison between the Edge and 09 Burner irons. I swung both at golf smith…that’s not a real comparison but the Edge felt really heavy/bulky compared to the Burners. That’s about all I can say fairly without a real comparison. I like Callaway “tools” and would prefer to own the Diablos just because they match my other Diablo tools (Driver, hybrid), but the Burners just feel better when I swing them and make contact with the ball. As a golf newbie, I’m not really sure what other benefit they would offer me over the Edge irons outside of comfort.
My other concern about the edge iron is that the sweet spot has been placed lower on the club meaning I could swing poorly and still hit the ball flush. How is that going to help me become a better golfer??? Moving the sweet spot means i would not get the same feed back as I would from a different GI club on miss hits. If I played very well with these I could still be playing poorly with lets say the Diablo Forged Irons or the TM R9s if I wanted to switch. My swing would need to change and I would be fighting muscle memory at that point. Now I have never took these to the range or the course, but you have. Please let me know that I am way off here and that the sweet spot thing is not that big of a deal. I could still pickup G15s and my swing would not need to change.
Comparing the Edge to the Burners is a personal thing. They both offer incredible distance, decent feel, and wonderful forgiveness.
ELOH,
Moving the sweet spot is not really what happened. They enlarged the sweet spot to include an area that most amateurs hit.
How do the Diablo Edge irons compare to the X-22s? What are the benefits of each?
Callaway is releasing a new X-series – the X-24 “hot.”
Can you compare the Diablo Edge to the X-24s? Especially for a high handicapper.
laid off golf for a few years due to work, etc. just got a combo set. these are the easiest clubs in the world to hit; however as i get a bit of my game back they are a little boring. nearly all shots are the same.
I too would love to know what you guys think about the Diablo Edges vs the Burner Super Launches.
Micah,
They are very different irons. The Diablo Edges are definitely geared towards long and straight similar to that of the Super Launches, and they are both very forgiving. But I find the Diablo Edge irons to have a little more performance and the Super Launch to have more assistance.