Club Champion wall of shafts

Club Champion CEO Nick Sherburne on Fitting, Growth and Private Equity

Last month, we took a broader look at private equity’s growing presence in golf and the tension that can come with outside investment, expansion and protecting the customer experience. Club Champion was part of that discussion, and CEO Nick Sherburne reached out afterward because he felt the company’s experience with private equity deserved a little more context. 

What followed was a fascinating conversation, and one that quickly moved well beyond private equity. We came away feeling like we had only scratched the surface of what Sherburne has learned during his time in the golf industry. 

He talked about why Club Champion pursued outside investment in the first place, what that money has helped fund, why he thinks the economics of golf club fitting are often misunderstood and how the post-COVID golf boom changed the way golfers think about equipment. 

Private Equity as a Tool for Growth 

Club Champion’s relationship with private equity goes back much further than many golfers probably realize. 

Sherburne says the company first took outside investment in 2010, then again in 2017 and 2019. Each time, the motivation was similar. Club Champion had grown beyond what he originally imagined, and outside capital gave the company a way to expand without relying entirely on founder capital. 

“When I started the business in 1998, I thought it would be one store,” Sherburne said. 

By 2010, that vision had changed considerably. Club Champion was beginning to see an opportunity to build something much larger than a handful of Chicago-area locations, and outside investment gave it the resources to pursue that growth. 

For Sherburne, though, expansion wasn’t simply about opening more stores. 

Club Champion SAM puttlab

He points to the infrastructure built around that growth as an equally important part of the story. Club Champion expanded its fitter-training program, added recruiting and field-training staff, invested in CRM and ERP systems, upgraded its fitting technology and built a roughly 30,000-square-foot facility with 24 builders and four quality-control checkpoints. 

Every new fitter now spends four weeks at Club Champion University before entering a studio, and the training doesn’t stop there. The company uses field trainers to continue that education and works with equipment partners to keep fitters current on new products and technology. 

That’s the version of private equity Sherburne wanted us to understand. In his view, the capital didn’t simply help Club Champion get bigger. It helped the company build the systems needed to support that growth while trying to preserve the fitting and build standards that were already in place, if not improve them substantially. 

He’s also clear about what he says hasn’t changed. 

Sherburne says Club Champion still sets its own budgets, determines its own operating priorities and controls how fittings are conducted. He also says investors haven’t dictated which products should be recommended, how fitters should sell or how clubs should be built. 

From his perspective, that’s why the relationship has worked. The company gained access to capital and infrastructure, but the decisions that directly shape the customer experience remained with Club Champion. 

Why Club Champion Costs What It Costs 

Price comes up often with Club Champion, and Sherburne doesn’t shy away from it. 

He readily acknowledges that the final cost of a fitting and custom build can be substantial, but he also thinks the conversation can become too focused on simply comparing the retail price of a head and shaft with the final price of a completed Club Champion build. 

His argument is that the product is really the entire process. 

That includes the fitting itself, access to a large matrix of heads and shafts, fitter expertise, technology and data collection, component sorting, swingweight, loft and lie work, SST PURE, quality control and the company’s Perfect Fit Guarantee. 

“We’re not simply selling golf club components,” Sherburne said. “We’re delivering an entire process designed to get a golfer from ‘What equipment should I play?’ to ‘This club was built specifically to perform the way we proved it could during my fitting.’” 

That doesn’t mean golfers can’t buy clubs for less, and Sherburne doesn’t pretend otherwise. His point is that comparing prices without accounting for everything around the club leaves part of the equation out. 

At the same time, he understands that budget will always be part of the conversation. 

Sherburne says fitters need to understand what a golfer is comfortable spending, and he’s quick to point out that expensive doesn’t automatically mean better. A lower-priced component can win the fitting, an existing club may only need an adjustment and, in some cases, the best answer may be to buy nothing at all. 

That last part becomes especially relevant when Sherburne talks about what he believes a successful fitting should look like. 

Has Golf Equipment Become Too Much About Brand and Price? 

Sherburne sees the COVID-era golf boom as an overwhelmingly positive thing for the game, but he also believes it changed how golfers educate themselves about equipment. 

Millions of new and returning golfers entered the market at roughly the same time equipment coverage exploded across YouTube, Reddit, social media, direct-to-consumer brands and traditional review sites. There’s more information available than ever, but Sherburne thinks that can sometimes make complicated equipment decisions feel simpler than they really are. 

What’s the best driver? What brand should I buy? How much does it cost? 

Those aren’t bad questions, but Sherburne thinks they can take attention away from the one that ultimately has to be answered: does the equipment actually work for the golfer swinging it? 

Titleist GTS3

That doesn’t mean expensive equipment is better. In fact, he argues the opposite. A $399 driver isn’t automatically a better value than a $599 driver, just as the more expensive option isn’t automatically the better performer. The same idea applies to direct-to-consumer brands and major OEMs. The golfer and the resulting performance are what determine whether something works. 

That perspective overlaps closely with one of THP’s core philosophies. 

We review a lot of golf equipment, but we’ve never believed one review can tell every golfer what belongs in the bag. It’s one reason THP has long emphasized consumer testing alongside staff testing, putting equipment directly into the hands of forum members and asking them to document their experiences over time. 

The idea is to provide more context, not declare a winner. Different swings, speeds and skill levels can produce very different results with the same piece of equipment, and hearing from more golfers helps paint a more complete picture. 

It’s also why THP doesn’t rank equipment. A club can be excellent and still be wrong for a particular golfer. Reviews can explain construction, technology, performance tendencies and firsthand experience, but a universal “best” list ignores too many individual variables to be especially meaningful. 

Sherburne summed up that distinction well. 

“A product review tells you about the product. A fitting tells you what the product does for you.” 

Those two things don’t have to compete. In fact, they probably work best together. 

More Information, More Preconceived Ideas 

Golfers also tend to walk into fittings with far more information than they did a decade ago. 

They’ve watched reviews, read forum discussions, researched shafts and compared launch characteristics before hitting a single ball in the studio. That knowledge can be useful, but it can also lead to some pretty firm expectations before the fitting even begins. 

Sherburne says golfers may arrive convinced they need a particular low-spin driver, shaft profile or iron because they’ve heard enough positive things about it online. Club Champion’s approach is to test those ideas rather than dismiss them. 

“Bring us the driver an influencer told you was the best. Bring the DTC iron you found online. Bring the shaft everyone on Reddit says you need. We’ll put it on TrackMan, establish a baseline and test it.” 

Trackman

That may be one of the most useful roles a fitting can play for an informed golfer. Research can help narrow the field and identify interesting products, while testing can show whether those products actually work. 

The same applies to brand loyalty. 

Sherburne says Club Champion has no issue with golfers arriving with a preferred manufacturer, and if that brand can produce the performance the golfer needs, everyone wins. If another option performs better, the fitter’s job is to show the difference and let the golfer make the decision. 

As Sherburne puts it, “Preference can start the fitting. Performance should inform the decision.” 

What Makes a Fitting Successful? 

Sherburne’s definition of a successful fitting may be the clearest summary of Club Champion’s philosophy. 

For him, success isn’t necessarily selling a set of golf clubs. 

It starts with figuring out what the golfer is trying to improve. Maybe that’s distance, dispersion, gapping, contact consistency or ball flight. From there, the fitter’s job is to determine whether equipment can help and, just as importantly, whether the data actually shows a meaningful improvement. 

Club Champion Fitting

Sometimes it won’t. 

Sherburne says that if a golfer’s current equipment performs as well as anything tested, telling that golfer to keep what they already own should still count as a successful fitting. 

That’s an important standard for a business that ultimately makes money selling fittings and clubs, and it also gets back to the broader theme running through the conversation. The goal, at least as Sherburne describes it, is to give the golfer enough information to make a better decision. 

Whether every customer experience lives up to that ideal is something golfers will judge for themselves. Sherburne himself says criticism based on an actual experience is fair. What he pushes back on is the assumption that Club Champion’s ownership structure alone tells golfers everything they need to know about the business. 

Our Take 

Private equity remains a complicated subject in golf, and Club Champion’s experience doesn’t tell us how every outside investment relationship will play out. 

What Sherburne’s perspective does provide is a more complete look at how Club Champion believes private equity has affected its own business. He points to nearly 16 years of outside investment and says that money has helped fund expansion, fitter education, technology, club building and the infrastructure needed to support a much larger footprint. 

His thoughts on the broader equipment climate are even more interesting, especially since it aligns with THP’s core mission in some ways.  

Golfers have access to more reviews, launch data, opinions and product information than ever before, and that’s a good thing. At the same time, knowing everything about a golf club still isn’t the same as knowing whether that club works for you. 

That distinction has always been important at THP. Staff reviews can offer experience and context, while consumer testing can broaden that perspective across different golfers. Neither replaces the need for the individual player to figure out what works for their own game. 

Maybe the most useful question isn’t which club is best. Instead, it’s the one Sherburne keeps coming back to: What works best for your swing, and can somebody prove it to you?

Go to discussion...

Social Media Director and Staff Writer Ryan Hawk lives in Northwestern Illinois. He's been a writer for The Hackers Paradise since 2011, and has been part of several THP Experiences.