Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Kuchar - Mayakoba Caddie Drama - Your Take?

Collapse

Below Nav Bar Ad

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by fflmaster View Post
    I have to disagree with you on this one. A caddie making less then 45,000 is being greedy by hoping/expecting that a VERY wealthy pro (who he helped win 1.3 MILLION) by wanting less than 40% of what a tour caddie would have received? You think 5,000 was fair? Only after sending the emails and this getting to the public did the offer of an additional 15,000 come into play.

    If anything, after all the good publicity Kuchar would have/did receive by winning this event he should have paid the club caddie close to the normal 130,000.

    To me, I always rooted for Kuchar. I thought he was a good golfer that I hoped would win in tournaments of the past. Now, he looks more like a rich elitist that only cares for himself. I will never root for him again.


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

    Where is this normal. A full time Tour Caddie with their own expenses? Maybe.

    That's a number that keep getting thrown around yet there's very little relation between the two relationships.
    Callaway GBB Epic 9* Matrix Red Tie
    Callaway GBB 15* Project X T800
    Callaway GBB 18* Project X T800
    Callaway Epic 24* Mitsubishi Kuro Kage
    Callaway CF16 Apex 5-PW Project X LZ
    Callaway Mac Daddy Forged 50* & 55*
    Titleist SM5 60*
    Odyssey O-Work 7s Black Edition
    Callaway Chromesoft

    Comment


    • I still like Kuch, just sayin. That's right, I said it. I said it online even which means forever and to infinity.
      Driver: M1 9.5 Won right here on THP!
      Fairway: GBB Epic 3w 14°, GBB EPIC 5w 18°
      Hybrid: X 416 4h 22°
      Irons: Apex CF19 5-AW XP 95
      Wedges: s18 54°, s18 58°
      Putter: Newport 2.0 Tour SNSR Contour Pro
      Grips: MCC +4
      Ball: Round with dimple


      Comment


      • Originally posted by ddec View Post
        and by "cheated" you mean he reviewed the situation with rules officials and they deemed there to be no penalty because he was in a waste area and not a bunker? Honestly, Cink hurt his reputation more by defeating Tom Watson in The Open.
        No.
        First of all Official Slugger White should have accompanied Cink to the waste bunker, but he chose instead to stay on the tee box and only talk about waste bunkers with Cink.
        Next, Cink went to the waste bunker alone and used his finger to dig a trench behind his ball, effectively build up a lie, which is cheating.
        Post round, after watching the video White knew he had screwed up (by not accompanying Cink to the waste bunker). But instead of doing the right thing and penalizing Cink , White decided to cover his own as$ and double talk his way out of it. For his part Cink could have penalized himself, but he chose not to do so.
        Driver: Ping G400 LST Graphite Design Tour AD IZ 6S
        Fairway metals: Cleveland Launcher HB 15* Miyazaki C.Kua 5S
        Hybrid: Cleveland Launcher HB 19* Miyazaki C.Kua 6S
        Irons: Ping G700 4-SW Project X LZ 5.5
        Wedge: Ping G400 58* LW Project X LZ 5.5
        Putter: Byron Morgan DH89 w/ putter grip

        Comment


        • Originally posted by Canadan View Post
          I am more impressed that you think this 'situation' is going to be discussed for another 20 years.
          Haha I don’t have an opinion but taking just core golfers, it died already until a publication wrote more on the subject.
          In my 2018 #TheGrandaddy THP Event Bag

          Driver:
          Epic Flash w/ Helium Shaft 45"
          Driver 2: XXIO Prime w/
          Custom THP HZRDUS Shaft 43.5"
          Fairway Wood:
          5 Wood
          Hybrids: Launcher HB
          Irons: Apex 19 w/ Recoil Proto 95
          Wedges:
          CBX 50* and RTX-4 56* & 60* PM Grind 19
          Putter: EXO Stroke Lab Marxman
          Balls:
          Chrome Soft X

          Comment


          • Originally posted by DG_1234 View Post
            Time will tell.
            This Kuchar story reminds me of when Stewart Cink cheated at Harbour Town, 2004. From that Cink "won the tournament" but in doing so his reputation was harmed and he still today has to answer questions about it. The $200,000 or so Cink gained (from taking 1st place versus 2nd place), was not worth the damage to his reputation and image.
            And yet after that time, Cink signed his most lucrative endorsement contract of his career.
            In my 2018 #TheGrandaddy THP Event Bag

            Driver:
            Epic Flash w/ Helium Shaft 45"
            Driver 2: XXIO Prime w/
            Custom THP HZRDUS Shaft 43.5"
            Fairway Wood:
            5 Wood
            Hybrids: Launcher HB
            Irons: Apex 19 w/ Recoil Proto 95
            Wedges:
            CBX 50* and RTX-4 56* & 60* PM Grind 19
            Putter: EXO Stroke Lab Marxman
            Balls:
            Chrome Soft X

            Comment


            • Originally posted by mikeg_74 View Post
              For a normal tour caddie I agree he deserves the bigger cut because it’s a reflection of the body of work and not a “one week rental” this situation presents. Again it isn’t set in stone that 10% is mandatory, the amount is an agreed upon percentage between caddie and player before the year starts.

              If I was a caddie at some resort and got lucky one week because a pro I worked for won and pockets $20, I would be happy because I just made kore money than I normally make.
              I agree he isn’t and shouldn’t be expecting the same 10%. I don’t know the norm and only can go by the article saying club caddies or one week rentals usually get the stated pay and a bonus depending on money won. I think a 2,000 bonus for winning 1.3 million is a bit of a slap in the face and showing of the kind of person Kuchar really is.

              It’s like in the restaurant business when a well known celebrity runs up a food bill of 1000, while you waited on them hand and foot. Then they tip you a 10. It just shows his true colors of the person he is and how he thinks of others.


              Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

              WITB:
              Driver:
              Rogue Draw 11° w/Even Flow ProjectX handcrafted 5.5 75G
              Fairway Woods: Epic 3+ Wood 13.5° w/Aldila Synergy R 50G and Rogue 4 Wood 17° w/ Aldila Synergy R 60G
              Hybrid: Rogue 4 20° Hybrid w/Aldila HY R 60G
              Irons: F9 ONE LENGTH 5 - AW w. Fujikura Atmos 6R One Length
              Wedges: Cleveland CBX 54° RTX-3 CB w/True Temper Dynamic Gold and Cleveland CBX 58° RTX-3 CB w/KBS Tour 90 R
              Putter 1: Marxman Stroke Lab
              Putter 2:Toulon Coming Soon
              Ball: Chrome Soft and ERC Triple Track

              Proud to be a member of the 2019 Odyssey Experience Team

              Comment


              • Originally posted by fflmaster View Post
                I agree he isn’t and shouldn’t be expecting the same 10%. I don’t know the norm and only can go by the article saying club caddies or one week rentals usually get the stated pay and a bonus depending on money won. I think a 2,000 bonus for winning 1.3 million is a bit of a slap in the face and showing of the kind of person Kuchar really is.

                It’s like in the restaurant business when a well known celebrity runs up a food bill of 1000, while you waited on them hand and foot. Then they tip you a 10. It just shows his true colors of the person he is and how he thinks of others.


                Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
                But that’s the thing, it was a $5k payment and a $15k bonus totaling $20k for the week....roughly 5times the monthly salary to be made for 4-5 days of work.

                If it does anything, it shows the true colors of El Tucán and his greed.
                In My #TheGrandaddy 2.0 Team Redemption Bag

                Callaway Epic Flash 10.5° | UST Elements Chrome F4
                Callaway Epic Flash 3+ 15.5° | Project X Even Flow Green 6.0
                Callaway Epic Flash Heavenwood 20° | Project X Even Flow Green 6.0
                Callaway CF-19 Apex Smoke Combo 5-AW | TT Elevate Tour Black S
                Callaway PM Grind 19 Tour Grey 54°/14 | 58°/12 | TT Elevate Tour Black S
                Toulon Stroke Lab Las Vegas | Chrome Soft **


                Comment


                • I am not sure why some are roasting Kuchar.

                  The caddie felt that $5k was a good number for 4 days of work. He worked 4 days. What did he do differently or in excess to warrant MORE pay?
                  Like others have said, the 10% deal is a guideline used for caddies who work the whole year, experiencing good weeks and bad weeks. Going to the course early to walk it and work on strategy. Invest time studying the greens and the weather/wind conditions.
                  Knowing the players likes and dislikes, packing the right food/drink. Working through the emotional ups and downs of the round. Knowing when to press him and when to back off...there is so much to it that the local caddie doesn't do, or is expected to do. He was paid to carry the bag and offer some lines off the tee boxes...Kuchar took care of the rest.

                  Lastly, if he wanted more money based on how he finished, he should have taken a commission approach and asked for a % of the winnings.

                  You can't go flat fee then bitch because you didn't want to take on any of the risk up front.
                  DRIVER: Callaway EPIC FLASHSZ 8* PROJ X WHITE T1100X
                  3WOOD: CallawayEPIC FLASH SZ HZRDS SMOKE S
                  3H: TMADE M6 TF
                  4i-AW: Taylormade P790 BLACK
                  WEDGES:CLEVELAND RTX 4 -54* MB BLACK/60* MB RAW
                  PUTTER: TOULON VEGAS STROKE LAB
                  DISTANCE GETTER - Garmin FENIX 5/LEUPOLD RANGE FINDER

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by DG_1234 View Post
                    No.
                    First of all Official Slugger White should have accompanied Cink to the waste bunker, but he chose instead to stay on the tee box and only talk about waste bunkers with Cink.
                    Next, Cink went to the waste bunker alone and used his finger to dig a trench behind his ball, effectively build up a lie, which is cheating.
                    Post round, after watching the video White knew he had screwed up (by not accompanying Cink to the waste bunker). But instead of doing the right thing and penalizing Cink , White decided to cover his own as$ and double talk his way out of it. For his part Cink could have penalized himself, but he chose not to do so.
                    and yet what is funny, I bet there are 10 people on the site who even know what we are talking about, and that number might be high. So just like that case, the Kuchar thing will be a non-story down the road.

                    "A few people called in about something that happened out there
                    in the waste area," Cink said. "The whole thing is made of little
                    rocks. I moved rocks out of the way, and I didn't want the rocks
                    to come in between the club and the ball." Cink felt certain that
                    he'd done everything right, because as soon as his ball landed in
                    the waste area he grabbed White and started asking questions.
                    "What can I do? Am I allowed to move this or not?" Cink said. "He
                    told me exactly what I was allowed to move, and I did what I was
                    told I could do."

                    Cink was right: The same rule (Rule 23-1) that allowed Tiger
                    Woods to have the gallery move a huge boulder that sat in his way
                    at the 1999 Phoenix Open allowed Cink to pick and flick little
                    stones and shell fragments from behind his ball. The problem is
                    that some callers had questioned whether Cink had improved his
                    lie. That's not allowed.

                    The debate moved to the Tour's video booth where the replay was
                    reviewed 10 to 12 times, and officials determined that Cink had
                    not, in fact, improved his lie. The small trench viewers saw
                    behind his ball was a rake mark that had been there before Cink
                    even approached. Cink was pleased with the ruling but a little
                    perturbed that it even came up. "Honestly, it was a little
                    stressful because you play and you win and you play great and
                    you're proud, then all of a sudden you have something you need to
                    address," he said. "So I'm not quite as happy as I was 30 minutes
                    ago."
                    Want to know what's in my FlexTech Bag Here ya go!

                    Cortex w/Aldila Rogue Silver 125 Stiff
                    G410 5 wood
                    Steelhead XR Heavenwood
                    Apex 4 & 5 hybrid
                    Apex '19 Combo 6-AW w/Catalyst 100 6.0
                    New Level M-Type 56 & 60
                    Spider X

                    Comment


                    • I would be surprised if this gets much more then the 15 mins of fame we are even giving this conversation here. Social media will probably pound on this for a day and then it’s gone by tomorrow.

                      Will Kuchar lose any endorsements? I HIGHLY doubt it.

                      Do I believe the club caddie was only paid 5k? ABSOLUTELY. Kuchar would have come out immediately if he gave more just to discredit the story and put everything on the club caddie. Kuchar wouldn’t have to say anything except the club caddie is incorrect. I paid him MORE then the 5k as the claim an believe I gave a fair amount. Leave it at that and the club caddie’s story is done.

                      Do I believe some will look at Kuchar in a more negative light? YES.




                      Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                      WITB:
                      Driver:
                      Rogue Draw 11° w/Even Flow ProjectX handcrafted 5.5 75G
                      Fairway Woods: Epic 3+ Wood 13.5° w/Aldila Synergy R 50G and Rogue 4 Wood 17° w/ Aldila Synergy R 60G
                      Hybrid: Rogue 4 20° Hybrid w/Aldila HY R 60G
                      Irons: F9 ONE LENGTH 5 - AW w. Fujikura Atmos 6R One Length
                      Wedges: Cleveland CBX 54° RTX-3 CB w/True Temper Dynamic Gold and Cleveland CBX 58° RTX-3 CB w/KBS Tour 90 R
                      Putter 1: Marxman Stroke Lab
                      Putter 2:Toulon Coming Soon
                      Ball: Chrome Soft and ERC Triple Track

                      Proud to be a member of the 2019 Odyssey Experience Team

                      Comment


                      • So at the Chinese buffet the other day our waitress went on break and another waitress actually handled 1 set of refills for our table. Should I have tipped her too?
                        Bucketsofjoy
                        WITB
                        In my bag
                        KING LTD 9° w/ V2
                        KING LTD 13°
                        Fly-Z Hybrid w/ VTS Silver
                        Rocketbladez Tour 4-AW
                        J15 54* & 58*
                        Abbie
                        Tour B XS

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by Bucketsofjoy View Post
                          So at the Chinese buffet the other day our waitress went on break and another waitress actually handled 1 set of refills for our table. Should I have tipped her too?
                          yes, but only 5k, 10% would be way too much
                          Launcher HB 10.5 AD DI 6S
                          Launcher HB 3W AD DI 6S
                          Launcher HB 3H oban Devotion 9
                          Launcher CBX 4-P Recoil 780 ES
                          CBX 48*Recoil 780 ES
                          RTX 54* high bounce KBS Custom White
                          RTX 60* low bounce KBS Custom White
                          m2
                          Z-star

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by MPlefty View Post
                            yes, but only 5k, 10% would be way too much
                            Gosh dangit. There goes my reputation.
                            Bucketsofjoy
                            WITB
                            In my bag
                            KING LTD 9° w/ V2
                            KING LTD 13°
                            Fly-Z Hybrid w/ VTS Silver
                            Rocketbladez Tour 4-AW
                            J15 54* & 58*
                            Abbie
                            Tour B XS

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by Bucketsofjoy View Post
                              Gosh dangit. There goes my reputation.
                              ...and me as a third party doesn't care, doesn't impact me. I still like you.


                              (see how this works)
                              Driver: M1 9.5 Won right here on THP!
                              Fairway: GBB Epic 3w 14°, GBB EPIC 5w 18°
                              Hybrid: X 416 4h 22°
                              Irons: Apex CF19 5-AW XP 95
                              Wedges: s18 54°, s18 58°
                              Putter: Newport 2.0 Tour SNSR Contour Pro
                              Grips: MCC +4
                              Ball: Round with dimple


                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by mikeg_74 View Post
                                But that’s the thing, it was a $5k payment and a $15k bonus totaling $20k for the week....roughly 5times the monthly salary to be made for 4-5 days of work.

                                If it does anything, it shows the true colors of El Tucán and his greed.
                                Ah, but the true payment was 3,000 with a 2,000 bonus.

                                The only reason the additional 15,000 came into play is because of the negative press this got after it was mentioned in the media.

                                How much one gets paid overall, be it 4 times their normal salary should not come into play. So, if I normally make 500 a day as a celebrity caddie, I should expect more then a club caddie making 100 a day?

                                How does it show the true colors of a man wanting to get paid what they believe their actions were worth? I believe the opposite. Shows his true character by not taking the 15,000 as that is a ton of money to him and his family because he believes in a principle that his actions/work was worth more.


                                Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

                                WITB:
                                Driver:
                                Rogue Draw 11° w/Even Flow ProjectX handcrafted 5.5 75G
                                Fairway Woods: Epic 3+ Wood 13.5° w/Aldila Synergy R 50G and Rogue 4 Wood 17° w/ Aldila Synergy R 60G
                                Hybrid: Rogue 4 20° Hybrid w/Aldila HY R 60G
                                Irons: F9 ONE LENGTH 5 - AW w. Fujikura Atmos 6R One Length
                                Wedges: Cleveland CBX 54° RTX-3 CB w/True Temper Dynamic Gold and Cleveland CBX 58° RTX-3 CB w/KBS Tour 90 R
                                Putter 1: Marxman Stroke Lab
                                Putter 2:Toulon Coming Soon
                                Ball: Chrome Soft and ERC Triple Track

                                Proud to be a member of the 2019 Odyssey Experience Team

                                Comment

                                Above Footer Ad

                                Collapse
                                Working...
                                X