Like Brian's response on page one, I'm a little puzzled by the question too? I'm just not seeing how good lie in a fairway bunker, no lip issues, comfortable yardage is that much different from a good lie in the rough, no tree issues, comfortable yardage. My assumption is the universal answer to both these straight forward scenarios would be to attempt to hit an approach to the green. I'm not suggesting it would always be successfully accomplished but why would anyone not at least try?