Best Girl Scout Cookies

JB

Follow @THPGolf on Social Media
Albatross 2024 Club
Staff member
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
281,798
Reaction score
423,306
Location
THP Experiences
This is the list available currently.

Screen Shot 2021-02-16 at 9.17.07 AM.png
Screen Shot 2021-02-16 at 9.16.58 AM.png
Screen Shot 2021-02-16 at 9.16.49 AM.png
 
Samoas #1
Thin Mints #2
 
gold: thin mints
silver: peanut butter patties
bronze: lemonades

weakest link: samoas :sick:
 
Tagalong. By a mile.
 
Thin Mints usually runs away with this but it is #3 for me. Do-si-dos and Shortbread are my top 2.
 
Carmel delites or samoas.. And no.. regardless of what people tell you they are not the same.. Samoas had darker chocolate and less coconut..

but girl scout cookies are too expensive so I buy the keebler coconut dream. Which is exactly the same as the Samoas..
 
Tagalongs



Everything else
 
Tagalongs
Thin Mints
 
It’s the boring choice for many, but the shortbread ones are my favorite. I could eat a whole box and not even bat an eye lol
 
Thin Mints!
 
My daughter is 8 and we just made our first deliveries this past weekend. Judging by orders Thin Mints and Tagalongs lead the way. Somoas are up there too

My favorite are the Smores

FB_IMG_1613490505853.jpg
FB_IMG_1613490370946.jpg
 
Taglongs
Samoa's
Thin Mints
 
Thin mints are #1
We just tried the Toast-Yay and they could take over as #1 as that are delicious.
 
Thin Mints
Samoa's
Tagalongs
 
I gave up sweets after the holidays. This is a real challenge.
Thin Mints are #1
Short Bread #2

I can live without the rest.
 
I like cookies, too. lol

If I had to choose three?

Caramel deLites

Tagalongs

Thin Mints
 
Thin mints barely beat out Tagalongs.
1613491221881.gif
 
refrigerated Samoas or Thin Mints are the only respectable answer
 
refrigerated Samoas or Thin Mints are the only respectable answer

Yes... Somoas always go in the freezer in my house.. Game changer..
 
Back
Top