We've launched the new forums! Read more here

Buffalo Fish Sandwich Better than Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Donald Trump GIF by Election 2016
 
Tevenor said:
Buffalo Fish Sandwich isn't even a thing in Buffalo.....this sounds like cultural culinary appropriation by southern states
Click to expand...
Funny thing is our house cleaner is from Buffalo and said she got down here and the wings are better here than in Buffalo.
 
Grouper is delicious, so I could see this being tasty... of course I'd throw ranch on it because I've lost all respect for myself.

I'd be down for buffalo fish "wings" as an appetizer too.
 
I’m in!
 
havent had one..but will have to disagree...love a good buffalo chicken sandwich
 
I have never thought to have a buffalo fish sandwich, and now i NEED to try it.
 
I'm not a huge fish sandwich kind of guy and I like a buffalo chicken so I'm going to join the disagree group.

I think more than the disagreement between the two, it's the fact that fish is not even close to its best form when on a sandwich.
 
OK, so I didn't know what to expect, but made one..... and now I'm a believer. So good. Did not expect it would work so well.
 
checkered said:
OK, so I didn't know what to expect, but made one..... and now I'm a believer. So good. Did not expect it would work so well.
Click to expand...
I know, right? It’s literally the perfect blend of crunch and soft when done properly and handles the sauce better than chicken
 
I have never seen it on a menu. I once had a buffalo shrimp hoagie that was fantastic, so I could see it being really good.
 
JB said:
I know, right? It’s literally the perfect blend of crunch and soft when done properly and handles the sauce better than chicken
Click to expand...
absolutely! It's so trippy but I'm floored how good it is. Thank you for sharing this take. I would have never tried otherwise.
 
Daluteh said:
I'm not a huge fish sandwich kind of guy and I like a buffalo chicken so I'm going to join the disagree group.

I think more than the disagreement between the two, it's the fact that fish is not even close to its best form when on a sandwich.
Click to expand...

Fish Tacos-----oooohhh ho ho yeah....sign me up

Fish sandwich ---ehhh... chicken probably better.

I am with you sir
 
JB said:
Well yeah, the THPer way. 🤣
Click to expand...
doesnt help that I really don't eat seafood at all.. lol ..but maybe someday
 
Buffalo style is for chicken.
Cajun style is for fish and chicken.

Not going anywhere near a Buffalo fish sandwich.
 
JimMLINY said:
Buffalo style is for chicken.
Cajun style is for fish and chicken.
Click to expand...
I will agree with this. Buffalo style is too overpowering of a flavor for the more delicate flavor of fish. Chicken can handle the stronger flavors like buffalo and Nashville hot, fish does not. Blackened/cajun style fish, you can still taste the fish. With buffalo, all you taste is buffalo.
If given the choice I will always choose fish over chicken when it comes to sandwiches, but I want to taste the fish not hide it in a strong sauce.
 
I think the problem here is that white meat chicken is just not very good in general. Almost every meat is better. Now buffalo fish is definitely not better than buffalo wings because wings have that beautiful dark meat chicken.
 
It’s awful
I havent tried it, but know it

THPers
 
rynobucket said:
I will agree with this. Buffalo style is too overpowering of a flavor for the more delicate flavor of fish. Chicken can handle the stronger flavors like buffalo and Nashville hot, fish does not. Blackened/cajun style fish, you can still taste the fish. With buffalo, all you taste is buffalo.
If given the choice I will always choose fish over chicken when it comes to sandwiches, but I want to taste the fish not hide it in a strong sauce.
Click to expand...
If all you can taste is buffalo when eating buffalo style, you’re not doing Buffalo correctly. Fish fry Buffalo style is delicious and you can still 100% taste the fish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JB
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top