We've launched the new forums! Read more here

Gimmes Late in a Match

Canadan

Canadan

LGND
Albatross 2025 Club
Staff member
Joined
May 16, 2010
Messages
159,115
Reaction score
129,726
Location
Midwest
Handicap
**
Since this was a debate during the Experience we just had with Srixon, I thought it'd be fun to hear perspective on gimmes.

If you're in a match and you're down or even with a couple to go, does your window for gimmes get smaller, or not change?

On top of that, do you like or dislike gimmes in matches?
 
Window gets smaller and I don’t mind gimmes in matches.
 
I've never been in the situation so I can only speak in hypotheticals, but I imagine I would want a winning putt to be holed. Outside of that, I think I'd be largely fine with gimmies.

We'll learn how I truly feel come December.
 
It definitely gets tighter as the round goes on. It’s also wider in a putt to halve the hole vs one to win it. I might want to see that 3 ft putt to beat me, especially if you are getting a pop, vs just giving it to you for the win.
 
Definitely gets smaller as it should IMO. I’d expect nothing less from my competitor unless they have given up.
 
@outlawx and I didnt give @Luke WilliamsCG a putt from 5ish feet to close us out. He was never missing it but I don’t feel bad having him put it out.
 
I would like to say that nothing changes. That if it were a gimme on the first, it would be a gimme on the 18th.

In reality, if I think you have a chance of missing it, there is a better chance I don't offer that gimme.
I neither like nor dislike gimmes. I would rather in a match to play assuming we both putt everything out. It eliminates expectations of a gimme.
Does it suck for pace though? Yes.
 
I must admit I’m a bit stingy with gimmes, but at the same time I never expect them from anyone.
 
It tends to shrink late in a match. But still keep it reasonable.
 
I know some good match players look at gimmes as a tactical decision. I really don’t want to win a hole because my opponent gagged on a 2 1/2 foot putt. I give short putts more than I probably should for that reason. The only time I make an opponent putt short ones is when he has rubbed me the wrong way early in the match.
 
I make people putt more often when the match gets tight. I actually like to give gimmies early just so my opponent doesn’t get to see a putt drop.
 
Window gets smaller and it’s smaller if it’s to win a hole. Ties are the largest area.

Window gets a lot smaller regardless of spot in the match, if the same putts aren’t reciprocated early.
 
Muchmore said:
Window gets smaller and it’s smaller if it’s to win a hole. Ties are the largest area.

Window gets a lot smaller regardless of spot in the match, if the same putts aren’t reciprocated early.
Click to expand...
The part of what happens early in the match is key. Don’t expect a 4 foot swinger when you make me putt a flat 3 footer.
 
Window has to get smaller and I don’t mind gimmies.
 
Don’t mind gimmes at all. Will get a little tighter as the match goes on and is close, but will still try to be reasonable.
 
Dislike the gimme, idea ( theoretically it’s good ) in its implementation , as it is subject to interpretation…it becomes ,,,
How long is a rubber band?

Without shadow of doubt , finish the hole that what your score is ,, it’s black and white .
 
I usually pawn off the gimme calls on my partner. I don’t know what I should or shouldn’t give. The explanation I got for determining what’s good is would I feel wrong to win by a missed putt of that length/difficulty. I kinda like that benchmark throughout the round and it’s what I’ll be using in the future. I don’t mind gimmes in match play and definitely don’t mind them in THP experiences.
 
I definitely think matches shouldn’t cordial. But asking to see a put that is on the edge should be expected by both sides. But let’s stay friendly.

Gimme’s should absolutely be a thing.. maybe even more important at THP events. Don’t be that guy.
 
Don't be a sore loser. Gimmie is a gimmie. Don't make em tap in if youre down. Shouldn't give questionable ones to begin with.
 
Not all 2-3 footers and matches are the same and it depends on what the outcome of the match really means.

In a friendly against a regular playing partner, what is a gimme early is a gimme late. Winning bragging rights must remain friendly as we were out there to have fun.

If the match means earning a point for your team or moving on in a tourney, I expect to putt 2-3 footers even if they seem like easy ones.

I have no issues with gimmes in match play.
 
Last edited:
Canadan said:
Since this was a debate during the Experience we just had with Srixon, I thought it'd be fun to hear perspective on gimmes.

If you're in a match and you're down or even with a couple to go, does your window for gimmes get smaller, or not change?

On top of that, do you like or dislike gimmes in matches?
Click to expand...
I like gimmes in matches. I do believe that they should get less generous late in matches, especially when a team is counting on you for a point.
 
Unless i’m down by a large amount, the answer is no, I dont want a THPer to lose by missing a short one.
 
The longer the match and the closer it is, I want to see the putt. I am more generous by far early in a match, for strategic reasons.
 
I think it's natural for the gimme range to shrink a bit later in matches and I like gimmes, it keeps the pace up.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top