The USGA handicap system. A story of “fairness “

Templet0n

Flawless victory!!
Albatross 2025 Club Albatross 2026 Club
Joined
Jun 7, 2019
Messages
73,707
Reaction score
82,999
Location
Reno, NV
Handicap
snow..
The US Open and the USGA handicap commercial has me very triggered. So to that respect. A story.. of fairness.

Oh, the USGA Handicap System. A marvel of modern mathematics, designed to bring parity to the golf course! Or so they say. For those of us blessed—or perhaps, cursed—with the ability to launch a golf ball into orbit, it's less a system of fairness and more a diabolical plot to ensure we never truly enjoy a round of golf.
Let me paint you a picture. You step up to the tee, a magnificent beast of a driver in your hands. You unleash a swing that would make Bryson DeChambeau weep tears of joy, and the ball rockets off the face, soaring majestically over trees, bunkers, and the very concept of "par 4." It lands, gently, 350 yards down the fairway, leaving you with a delicate pitch to the green. Birdie opportunity, right? Wrong.
Because, you see, the USGA Handicap System, in its infinite wisdom, looks at that towering drive and says, "Ah, yes, this golfer is clearly too good." It then proceeds to punish you for your natural athletic prowess. Your reward for consistently splitting fairways at unimaginable distances? A handicap so low it practically requires you to chip in from the parking lot just to make net par.
Meanwhile, your playing partner, bless their heart, shanks one into the woods, sculls another into the water, and finally tops a third that dribbles a mere 100 yards. They hack their way to a respectable (for them) bogey, and the system, in its infinite benevolence, rewards them with strokes. Strokes! For what? For artistic interpretation of a golf swing? For exploring the natural flora and fauna of the course?
It's a system that actively discourages improvement. Why bother spending hours on the range, honing your swing, building the strength to unleash a prodigious drive, when all it means is you'll have to play against a ghost score that demands perfection? It’s like being penalized for being able to run a four-minute mile – “Oh, you’re too fast, we’ll just add 30 seconds to your race time so it’s fair for everyone else.”
The USGA Handicap System is, at its core, a socialist manifesto disguised as a golf rulebook. It seeks to level the playing field by kneecapping the talented. It's a system designed by golfers who probably can't hit it more than 220 yards, and thus, feel the need to impose their limitations on those of us who can.
So, the next time you see a long hitter sighing dramatically after another incredible drive, understand their pain. They’re not just admiring their shot; they’re mentally calculating how many strokes that majestic blast is going to cost them in the grand, unfair scheme of the USGA Handicap System. We are the oppressed, the perpetually penalized for our gifts, forced to play a game where our very strengths are our undoing. It's truly a tragedy, one 350-yard drive at a time.\




Yes, Ai helped me with this and I thought it was pretty funny.
 
You're not wrong.... lol
 
I get the feelings that giving up pops makes it harder to win matches against players that you are clearly better than.

But this write up is makes it seem like the handicap system takes strokes away from you when it doesn't. Your par is still a par, birdie is still a birdie. I get you may need a birdie to beat the net par but it doesn't add strokes to your score. This simply an error filled rant.
 
I get the feelings that giving up pops makes it harder to win matches against players that you are clearly better than.

But this write up is makes it seem like the handicap system takes strokes away from you when it doesn't. Your par is still a par, birdie is still a birdie. I get you may need a birdie to beat the net par but it doesn't add strokes to your score. This simply an error filled rant.
It is just sarcasm. But, the system 100% does penalize me. That is fact.
 
I don't think AI understands how the handicap system works at all based on that.
 
Why do you hate puppies and angels?
 
There is nothing in the Rules of Golf that mandates you play with a golf handicap or compete using handicaps. There are plenty of opportunities for players to compete on a gross basis. It is your choice whether to play using handicaps or solely scratch.

I somewhat agree with the idea that the golf handicap system can breed complacency with some higher handicappers. In our senior club, some members spend more time nurturing their handicap index than practicing.
 
Handicaps would work better if people would simply report every score properly. But they dont because people are so good at lying to themselves, much less others.
 
Come On Wtf GIF
 
This was just in humor.. Don't take it too seriously. lol
 
I get the feelings that giving up pops makes it harder to win matches against players that you are clearly better than.

But this write up is makes it seem like the handicap system takes strokes away from you when it doesn't. Your par is still a par, birdie is still a birdie. I get you may need a birdie to beat the net par but it doesn't add strokes to your score. This simply an error filled rant.
As wild as the AI rant is...if someone is a plus handicap, it absolutely would add strokes to your score. So a +2 HC would need to shoot birdie on the #17 and 18 HC holes to shoot par on them.

If playing match play though, you'd typically just add 2 more to the higher cap most likely. But stroke play it would count as two extra strokes for them.
 
This is me really just complaining that my handicap has not traveled well.
 
As wild as the AI rant is...if someone is a plus handicap, it absolutely would add strokes to your score. So a +2 HC would need to shoot birdie on the #17 and 18 HC holes to shoot par on them.

If playing match play though, you'd typically just add 2 more to the higher cap most likely. But stroke play it would count as two extra strokes for them.
Net par. The plus handicapper still had a birdie.
 
It is just sarcasm. But, the system 100% does penalize me. That is fact.
I know this is a for fun one, but I'm too curious. How does it penalize you?
 
The last year or two have made me seriously consider stopping competitive golf unless it’s my buddies who are basically the same skill as me. It just seems like low cappers hate handicapped events and they ruin your time when they lose.
 
I know this is a for fun one, but I'm too curious. How does it penalize you?
I hit the ball far and play at altitude. Interestingly the distance of the course honestly has very little impact on my score. So the handicap system has me at basically a 1 handicap. When I shoot in the high 70s low 80s It had me at a plus a one point even though I basically never shot under par.. I was playing better, but it was still always scores in the high 70s.. But I play courses that are over 7k yards almost all the time.
 
I know it was (mostly lol) in jest but at first glance it feels unfair

However, imagine playing tennis against someone who is awful. Even a fun underhand serve game is frustrating for both
In golf, a match can be made against literally anybody. I
As a benefactor, I selfishly love the handicap system.
 
The last year or two have made me seriously consider stopping competitive golf unless it’s my buddies who are basically the same skill as me. It just seems like low cappers hate handicapped events and they ruin your time when they lose.
That is never my goal and I wouldn't complain. I just need to score better and get my handicap to travel. I also only ever play anything handicapped at THP events. So it really doesn't affect me or 99% of my golf.
 
The US Open and the USGA handicap commercial has me very triggered. So to that respect. A story.. of fairness.

Oh, the USGA Handicap System. A marvel of modern mathematics, designed to bring parity to the golf course! Or so they say. For those of us blessed—or perhaps, cursed—with the ability to launch a golf ball into orbit, it's less a system of fairness and more a diabolical plot to ensure we never truly enjoy a round of golf.
Let me paint you a picture. You step up to the tee, a magnificent beast of a driver in your hands. You unleash a swing that would make Bryson DeChambeau weep tears of joy, and the ball rockets off the face, soaring majestically over trees, bunkers, and the very concept of "par 4." It lands, gently, 350 yards down the fairway, leaving you with a delicate pitch to the green. Birdie opportunity, right? Wrong.
Because, you see, the USGA Handicap System, in its infinite wisdom, looks at that towering drive and says, "Ah, yes, this golfer is clearly too good." It then proceeds to punish you for your natural athletic prowess. Your reward for consistently splitting fairways at unimaginable distances? A handicap so low it practically requires you to chip in from the parking lot just to make net par.
Meanwhile, your playing partner, bless their heart, shanks one into the woods, sculls another into the water, and finally tops a third that dribbles a mere 100 yards. They hack their way to a respectable (for them) bogey, and the system, in its infinite benevolence, rewards them with strokes. Strokes! For what? For artistic interpretation of a golf swing? For exploring the natural flora and fauna of the course?
It's a system that actively discourages improvement. Why bother spending hours on the range, honing your swing, building the strength to unleash a prodigious drive, when all it means is you'll have to play against a ghost score that demands perfection? It’s like being penalized for being able to run a four-minute mile – “Oh, you’re too fast, we’ll just add 30 seconds to your race time so it’s fair for everyone else.”
The USGA Handicap System is, at its core, a socialist manifesto disguised as a golf rulebook. It seeks to level the playing field by kneecapping the talented. It's a system designed by golfers who probably can't hit it more than 220 yards, and thus, feel the need to impose their limitations on those of us who can.
So, the next time you see a long hitter sighing dramatically after another incredible drive, understand their pain. They’re not just admiring their shot; they’re mentally calculating how many strokes that majestic blast is going to cost them in the grand, unfair scheme of the USGA Handicap System. We are the oppressed, the perpetually penalized for our gifts, forced to play a game where our very strengths are our undoing. It's truly a tragedy, one 350-yard drive at a time.\




Yes, Ai helped me with this and I thought it was pretty funny.
Good, fun read. Thanks for sharing.

Myself, I haven't paid attention to the hdcp system. I have one, but I let the league secretary worry about it. I just turn in my scores.
 
I know this is in jest, but it does bring up a point of if the system should better incentivize improvement. My understanding of the math the underpins the entire thing is based on a 90% factor that is intended to give a slight edge to the lower cap. Should it be more?
 
my match later this afternoon...that's a lot of pops to try and fade.
and it's worth noting that my course handicap is lower than my index, while his is higher than his index. socialist conspiracy! :ROFLMAO:

smh.jpg
 
Back
Top