If Phil or Tiger were reasonably competent QBs, sure it would be fun to get them in a live NFL game and watch them try to match up with Peyton or Brady.I guess it's a personal choice. I've been to lots of Pro Ams and do not like watching the amateurs play, too many bad shots.
On this thread , a couple of times I've posed the question "do you want to see Tiger or Phil throw a football"? To me that's the same thing as watching football players on a golf course. I don't want to see Tiger or Phil throw a football but maybe some people do. To each his/her own.
Watching them "throw a football" would be about as interesting as watching Lefty and Tiger with Peyton and Brady at the driving range. Completely different thing.