Pick Your QB: RG3 or Manziel?

Dr RosenRosen · Jan 13, 2016

You have just been hired as the GM of a new NFL franchise. The owner gives you an ultimatum: Pick one QB to lead the franchise for the next five years - Robert Griffin III or Johnny Manziel. After confirming your owner's sanity, and after arguments with him to pick any other QB ("Hey, I think Clipboard Jesus is available in Indy!"), you relent.

You watch the film. You confirm the stories about the "coach killer" and "Johnny Football," stories that have you finishing off a second bottle of Crown. Both Griffin and Manziel are available and at the same price.

Who ya got?

Jank · Jan 13, 2016

Manziel, I guess. Not sure my job would last the 5 years, though.

ddec · Jan 13, 2016

I choose a different franchise

Scarnici · Jan 13, 2016

I'm taking RG3 and I am never setting up my office

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Just_Brad · Jan 13, 2016

RG3. Manziel's antics scare the hell out of me.

JB · Jan 13, 2016

ddec said:
I choose a different franchise

Me too, if I had to choose, its RG III, just based on character.

Paladin · Jan 13, 2016

Hoyer. Lindley. Johnny Moxom from Varsity Blues. Keanu Reeves, simply because he played a QB in a movie.

All people I would pick to have under center over Griffin and Manziel.

If I have to choose, I go with Manziel because aside from a concussion I'd call questionable because he doesn't have a brain, his injury history is pretty scant compared to Griffin.

Awkward silence · Jan 13, 2016

RG3 will actually show up to meetings and games, I am going with the guy that shows not hungover/drunk... so RG3

ddec · Jan 13, 2016

JB said:
Me too, if I had to choose, its RG III, just based on character.

I think that's the obvious choice.

Mmaynard11 · Jan 13, 2016

Are we talking college QB?

#Cookie · Jan 13, 2016

ddec said:
I choose a different franchise

Unfortunately this may be our reality buddy.

JP_CO · Jan 13, 2016

I would just quit.
Can we just call on the water boy?

Pokeslice · Jan 13, 2016

I would go with Manziel because I think rg3's knee might break just by looking at it. But I would take Timmy T over both of them.

Mmaynard11 · Jan 13, 2016

I'm going blind hat draw hoping for RG3

#Cookie · Jan 13, 2016

If the Cowboys have to get one, give me Manziel. We have a habit of bringing in questionable characters so why stop now. Talent wise....Manziel has more.

Wake · Jan 13, 2016

I'd take RG3 and it's not close

Agent Jay · Jan 13, 2016

This is like choosing if you want to run a mile, or run a mile in heat. I don't WANT to do either, but if I had to choose....

Manziel has less injuries on him....IF he'd just get his head on straight, he might be able to win. He showed passion against the Chiefs when they played in Arrowhead, so I know it's there somewhere. I guess I choose him.

Might as well flip a quarter.

Scrap Iron · Jan 13, 2016

I would resign.

Michigan Slice · Jan 13, 2016

Paging PhillyV....

Myself, good lord...
That's one hell of a predicament to put yourself in..

sixcat · Jan 13, 2016

If I were to ever place myself in a situation such as this, I would take a long, hard look at my life and decision making skills, or lack thereof.

UglySwing · Jan 13, 2016

That's like asking someone to choose if they want diarrhea or constipation.

I'll go Manziel because it's far more likely he does something so incredibly stupid, the entire fan base will understand why you're dropping him, and why you're now stuck with a game manager type for the rest of the season.

With RG3, it's going to take longer to convince fans he's an epic fail because it's mainly his on field performance that will suck. Manziel will suck on and off the field.