Putter Grip Similar to Scotty Mid-size Matador?

I put a SuperStroke Pistol 2.0 on my Spider, and I feel like I want to change to something a little different. I really like the feel of the midsize Matadors on the Scotty putters, and would like to find something close to that to try on my Spider.

I picked up a Winn midsize pistol, and their midsize pistol triple line, and they seem to be pretty close, but they were just loose grips....not actually installed on a putter, so hard to say for sure.

Any other suggestions?

I put a Golf Pride SNSR 140 straight on my Futura 5s. It is close in size to the midsize Matador. I believe it was about 1/8 to 1/4 inch larger in circumference.