Golf has plenty of official rules, but somehow, golfers have invented an entirely separate rulebook of things you’re just supposed to know. In Episode 08 of Splitting Fairways, Hawk and Tox take on Golf’s Dumbest Unwritten Rules and try to figure out where legitimate etiquette ends and pointless golf judgment begins.
Hats indoors. Untucked shirts. Denim. Changing your shoes in the parking lot. Too many headcovers. 14-way bags. And, of course, the undisputed heavyweight champion of unnecessary golf arguments: iron covers. If none of these things affect another golfer’s round, why does anyone care? Ryan (Hawk) and Jeremy (Lord Tox) debate which traditions still have a place in the game, and which ones golfers need to stop taking so seriously.
Then they head to the course to tackle the unwritten rules that might actually matter. Should honors on the tee give way to ready golf? Is talking to someone else’s ball harmless encouragement or an unforgivable offense? Can you call a putt before it drops? And do you really need to gently place the flagstick on the green?
Not every unwritten rule deserves to disappear. Repairing pitch marks, raking bunkers, keeping pace, respecting another player’s concentration, and taking care of the course all make golf better for everyone. Maybe that’s the real test, the best etiquette usually makes golf better for somebody other than you.
If you could erase one unwritten rule from golf tomorrow, which one goes?
Podcast: Play in new window | Download



Talking to other’s golf ball is a bad habit for me, but I agree with [USER=1193]@Hawk[/USER] – it just comes from a place of wanting people to hit good shots.
Great discussion, I don’t get the hat rule but I don’t play at fancy courses
[QUOTE=”MikeG, post: 14250673, member: 15992″]
Untucked shirts are 90/10 for me. 90% of the time it’s tucked in and I don’t have issues with it becoming untucked during my round. There are some times that I play a solo twilight round and the shirt it untucked for no reason than its a more casual round.
[/QUOTE]
I untuck all summer because I want as much airflow as possible. I’m probably 90/10 tucked in cooler weather, especially if I’m going to wear a qzip or jacket over my polo, I think untucked tails under an outer garment look sloppy.
Of course, if I’m playing somewhere that requires a tucked shirt, I’ll tuck regardless of the weather, but those courses are pretty few and far between. Just like courses that don’t want you changing shoes in the parking lot – I think that’s mostly high-end private country clubs, and it’s not often I get to play one of those.
Great episode, gents.
Hats off inside, always even when not golfing. Born and raised in the south, spent some time in the army – too much potential for a foot in the ass if a hat was worn inside.
The golf shoes in the locker room thing is born out of practicality from the metal spike era. You’re not walking through the parking lot with spark blasters, you’re not wrecking “the grand entryway” of the clubhouse to check in. Most clubs were designed where walking out of the locker room didn’t take you back through the entry way, dining area, etc. it would send you out to the range or near the first tee where you’d meet your caddy with your bag.
I happen to like the idea of it even now with soft spikes/spikeless as long as the club is set up for it with lockers etc. tradition, nostalgia for a lost era – all of that.
But I’m also typically strolling in the proshop to check in and grab a cart key in flip flops, then go back to the truck and put on the boots and load up.
So, the duality of man….
Headcovers on until the shot, then immediately replaced.
Flagstick goes down gently. If your ball is closest, you get the honor of flag duty. And it’s a weird flex that I don’t get to enjoy as often as I’d like.
**edit –
Also I don’t understand the “walking in the thru line” of someone else’s put “if they go past the hole”. If someone ever got lippy about that to me, I would make the suggestion that they don’t miss the putt then.
[QUOTE=”cmon man, post: 14251234, member: 68593″]
Great as usual guys. A little ageist haha. What is your stance on white belts? That one seems to have died down as a not button topic.
[/QUOTE]
I still like the look occasionally tbh. The problem is that it’s become a meme and I feel like I can’t wear it. I do have lighter belts I wear, but they aren’t white.
[QUOTE=”TWright, post: 14251627, member: 11048″]
This was a fun listen. The headcover hate from a guy using a 15 way bag was funny.
Though I dont understand people taking off and leaving the headcovers off the whole round.
Denim on course seemed way more prevalent back in the day which is funny cause today’s jeans with the poly blend would probably be way more comfortable than denim of old.
The hat off thing I don’t get people getting bothered by it. If those are the rules of the club what’s so hard about it. Though if someone forgets just nicely remind them, no need to ridicule.
I’m a fat dude and prefer to tuck my polo shirt in while golfing, but occasionally it will come un tucked and I’m not bothering with it while on the course.
[/QUOTE]
To be fair, it’s not head cover hate. I have a bunch in my bag. I’m just being honest lol – and some of that is purely self awareness.
[QUOTE=”MulliganStation, post: 14252045, member: 86749″]
Great episode, gents.
Hats off inside, always even when not golfing. Born and raised in the south, spent some time in the army – too much potential for a foot in the ass if a hat was worn inside.
The golf shoes in the locker room thing is born out of practicality from the metal spike era. You’re not walking through the parking lot with spark blasters, you’re not wrecking “the grand entryway” of the clubhouse to check in. Most clubs were designed where walking out of the locker room didn’t take you back through the entry way, dining area, etc. it would send you out to the range or near the first tee where you’d meet your caddy with your bag.
I happen to like the idea of it even now with soft spikes/spikeless as long as the club is set up for it with lockers etc. tradition, nostalgia for a lost era – all of that.
But I’m also typically strolling in the proshop to check in and grab a cart key in flip flops, then go back to the truck and put on the boots and load up.
So, the duality of man….
Headcovers on until the shot, then immediately replaced.
Flagstick goes down gently. If your ball is closest, you get the honor of flag duty. And it’s a weird flex that I don’t get to enjoy as often as I’d like.
**edit –
Also I don’t understand the “walking in the thru line” of someone else’s put “if they go past the hole”. If someone ever got lippy about that to me, I would make the suggestion that they don’t miss the putt then.
[/QUOTE]
I will remember that last part if it ever comes up. tbh, if you miss that far past the hole you have more problems than a footprint.
[QUOTE=”MulliganStation, post: 14252045, member: 86749″]
Also I don’t understand the “walking in the thru line” of someone else’s put “if they go past the hole”. If someone ever got lippy about that to me, I would make the suggestion that they don’t miss the putt then.
[/QUOTE]
For real. It’s not my job to guess where you’re next shot might end up and avoid that location. I go out of my way to avoid everyone’s current line, but the next shot line, is just a silly expectation.
Unwritten rule: don’t stand in my peripheral when I’m swinging. 🤓
[QUOTE=”shanewu, post: 14253918, member: 38120″]
Unwritten rule: don’t stand in my peripheral when I’m swinging. 🤓
[/QUOTE]
How are we supposed to watch the ball if we aren’t standing directly behind or to the side of you?
[QUOTE=”Lord Tox, post: 14254177, member: 5944″]
How are we supposed to watch the ball if we aren’t standing directly behind or to the side of you?
[/QUOTE]
That’s a good one actually. I do think it’s an unwritten rule that you’ll help watch the golf ball and help find it if possible.
[QUOTE=”Hawk, post: 14254192, member: 1193″]
That’s a good one actually. I do think it’s an unwritten rule that you’ll help watch the golf ball and help find it if possible.
[/QUOTE]
Especially as you get older and your eyes ain’t what they used to be.
…not that I’d know or anything, just sayin’.
[QUOTE=”Lord Tox, post: 14254177, member: 5944″]
How are we supposed to watch the ball if we aren’t standing directly behind or to the side of you?
[/QUOTE]
I totally agree with this.
There are people that do stand really close to the point you think you are going to “catch them” on the takeaway.
[QUOTE=”Hawk, post: 14254192, member: 1193″]
That’s a good one actually. I do think it’s an unwritten rule that you’ll help watch the golf ball and help find it if possible.
[/QUOTE]
At this point… my depth perception is terrible. I will take all the help I can get.
[QUOTE=”THE BOV, post: 14254223, member: 41109″]
At this point… my depth perception is terrible. I will take all the help I can get.
[/QUOTE]
That’s my biggest issue as well it seems. Sad lol
[QUOTE=”THE BOV, post: 14254223, member: 41109″]
At this point… my depth perception is terrible. I will take all the help I can get.
[/QUOTE]
I can see the ball till it starts its descent. Then its just a guess
[QUOTE=”Lord Tox, post: 14254250, member: 5944″]
I can see the ball till it starts its descent. Then its just a guess
[/QUOTE]
You and me teaming up to watch golf balls is just a waste of time lol
[QUOTE=”Hawk, post: 14254192, member: 1193″]
That’s a good one actually. I do think it’s an unwritten rule that you’ll help watch the golf ball and help find it if possible.
[/QUOTE]
When playing with my father it’s barely even an unwritten rule. He says it on every tee box to me to come help watch his ball that I’ve considered having cards made that say it for him.
[QUOTE=”Lord Tox, post: 14254250, member: 5944″]
I can see the ball till it starts its descent. Then its just a guess
[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=”Hawk, post: 14254259, member: 1193″]
You and me teaming up to watch golf balls is just a waste of time lol
[/QUOTE]
If the 3 of us are ever in the same group that 4th better have 20/20.
[QUOTE=”THE BOV, post: 14254368, member: 41109″]
If the 3 of us are ever in the same group that 4th better have 20/20.
[/QUOTE]
[IMG alt=”Katniss Everdeen I Volunteer As Tribute GIF”]https://media1.giphy.com/media/74ZOAgI9Al0Dm/200.gif[/IMG]
(I don’t have 20/20 anymore but it sounds like fun)
[QUOTE=”THE BOV, post: 14254368, member: 41109″]
If the 3 of us are ever in the same group that 4th better have 20/20.
[/QUOTE]
I have 20/20 now after lasik and feel I see the ball worse than I did with contacts.
[QUOTE=”LeftyGolferWI, post: 14250184, member: 77319″]
I cannot for the life of me understand why ANYONE would want to play golf in jeans or jorts. Lol.
As mentioned earlier this week in another thread, I see it at my home course on a weekly basis. Which is a “Country Club,” but is really public with membership options.
[/QUOTE]
I grew up sort of in the sticks. I grew up where we did not have many clothes so you wore what you had. I wore jeans for baseball, basketball, tennis, and yeah…some rounds of golf. Very comfortable when you are used to them.
Do I today? No, but that is a casual nod to peer pressure. They are far more comfortable and better looking than most golf apparel to me.
[QUOTE=”JB, post: 14250261, member: 3″]
Its viewed by many the same as[B] having to move up a tee[/B], iron covers, etc.
[/QUOTE]
new sad shame unlocked….
if it is unwritten it ain’t a rule…just something some people would wish happened and others don’t care about.
where it is written, then it IS a rule and I will follow to the best of my ability.
I am definitely leaning hard toward non-traditional because I found myself taking the opposition on virtually every take, and some of them…who gets to decide what looks better? I never think someone looks better with tucked shirt. Quite the opposite. On the other hand, I really don’t care what others look like on the course, not there for a fashion show.
And to the comment the chatter sounds good…uh…no. Awful. Wish it could be banned, club chatter is the absolute worst. At the same time, to each their own. I try to avoid it but if others want it, knock themselves out.
And I am one of the people who does try to watch everyone’s ball, but if I am not standing behind, and I stand generally 20ish feet or so behind, there is zero chance I will see it. I can’t pick it up from the side so if people ask me not to stand there, obviously I won’t…but I also will not be able to see your ball flight. Just an unfortunate fact of life and as others have stated, when the ball starts descent I lose it so I am following the line of flight and expected distance more than anything.
[QUOTE=”darthweasel, post: 14254627, member: 32906″]
new sad shame unlocked….
[/QUOTE]
Let’s add moving up a tee into the Venn diagram in the other thread too.
[QUOTE=”BigMac, post: 14254993, member: 3386″]
Let’s add moving up a tee into the Venn diagram in the other thread too.
[/QUOTE]
it is something I love doing. I like playing up 2, even 3 boxes. I feel mighty lol
Just finished this one.
Biggest ones for me is I’m ready golf except on the tee we play honors regardless of birdie or par or bogey. It’s always a fun way to give each other crap about being on the back of the box still. So honors on the box, but I’ll be marking my ball and lining it up while you’re putting because the green is where people take way too long. If that bothers people, I will stop no problem, but unless it’s asked, I’ll make sure I’m ready to play and I’ll play out of turn if you’re dealing with a tricky line or something.
I used to be SOOOOOO against tucking in my shirt. I can show up to the course in athletic shorts and a workout shirt and be fine, but if I have a polo on, it’s tucked in.
I don’t understand how dropping a pin is anywhere close to something that is a concern. People walking is more of an issue than me dropping the pin from waist height. Tip is already set down so nothing is hurting, or can hurt, the green.
People with headcovers staying off during the round are absolute lunatics
I change shoes in the parking lot every single time I go to play. Non Dormie course obviously.
[QUOTE=”Lord Tox, post: 14254177, member: 5944″]
How are we supposed to watch the ball if we aren’t standing directly behind or to the side of you?
[/QUOTE]
Behind and to the left is fine. One of the older guys I play with stands right behind my backswing line and he can’t see the ball after it’s like 100y away so no benefit from him. 😂
Here’s one that wasn’t discussed: If you pick up the flagstick while others are still putting and it’s windy, don’t let the flag flap around and make noise. Either pin it down to the flagstick with your hand, or hold the flagstick upside down with the flag at the ground (not an American flag, obviously).
[QUOTE=”PhillyV, post: 14249936, member: 6890″]
This is one that I wasnt really aware bothered people. Im not a member at a club and rarely have access to a locker room or changing room so the parking lot is where I do my work lol
[/QUOTE]
Shoes? I will change my pants and shirt in the parking lot at my league courses.
[QUOTE=”1860VS, post: 14256296, member: 71354″]
Shoes? I will change my pants and shirt in the parking lot at my league courses.
[/QUOTE]
Outside of the car? I’ve done changes in the car if I’m coming from work and there’s nowhere inside
[QUOTE=”PhillyV, post: 14256428, member: 6890″]
Outside of the car? I’ve done changes in the car if I’m coming from work and there’s nowhere inside
[/QUOTE]
Yep. Park next to a bush, stand between both open doors and I have my own locker room, without the nastiness on the floor…. just have to watch for ticks if I get too close to the bushes.
[QUOTE=”1860VS, post: 14256432, member: 71354″]
Yep. Park next to a bush, stand between both open doors and I have my own locker room, without the nastiness on the floor…. just have to watch for ticks if I get too close to the bushes.
[/QUOTE]
Eh everyone does their own thing but that’s a bit much for me