Philly Golf Guy
#PGG
- Joined
- Nov 7, 2012
- Messages
- 9,103
- Reaction score
- 7
- Handicap
- USGA 14
Today I showed up for the full bag fitting at the local Club Champion. Steve was my fitter. It turned out we spent so much time with the irons, that we went through the putting fitting, then scheduled another day for the woods and hybrids (although I did hit a few hybrids before we made that decision).
I showed up with my bag and a few different clubs. I brought a few different irons and a couple putters, as I've been switching between all of them lately and part of the reason I was there was to sort all of this out and figure out what would be ideal.
Let me start off by saying I really enjoyed the fitting immensely. My two main goals relating to irons and putters were more than satisfied. But in all honesty, things didn't start off all that well and I was a little put off during the initial discussion. He wanted to know what I was looking to get out of the fitting. I told him I really wanted to figure out the ideal iron shaft for me, check out some iron heads, and spend a lot of time finding the right hybrid/fairway wood combination for my distance game. He asked what irons I was interested in, I told him Adams CB3, to which he just said, "that's out; they don't even make that any more." Ok then. I think he was annoyed I showed up with a few different irons and he wanted me to commit to one. That was fair enough. He then asked what ball I play, so I told him, and he wanted to know why. I told him my last fitting told me to hit them and I liked them, and he kind of laughed it off, telling me the only way to get the ideal ball was to try them all outside during play (although this was like a 5 minute lecture). It felt like the whole schpiel was to show me how little I knew and ridiculous my past equipment decisions were and that I was lucky I would now be set right. At any rate, it was a little rocky start and I'd be lying if I didn't say I was thinking about bagging the whole thing then and there. Fortunately I didn't and I ended up liking my session with Steve a lot.
I warmed up and sure enough, I got my typical "fitter frenzy," where I forget how to hit a golf ball. This has happened every time I've been fit for irons. I managed to hit enough OK shots for him to get some readings. We then talked a little bit about my swing, my transition and what he was thinking in terms of shafts. He discussed numbers with me, including landing angle, which is essentially how the ball starts descending from its peak. He ideally wanted the ball to gradually rise to its peak, then start falling much steeper. He also talked about spin numbers and explained that spin is my friend to keep the ball in the air. Smash factor, ball speed and others were discussed; I'm still digesting it all, but it was helpful. Specifically, he thought I needed a heavier and stiffer shaft, which was a relief to me, because that's how I've recently felt with my swing has been with my current set. I was to hit 6 balls in each shaft/head combination. We started out with a Nippon shaft in regular flex in steel (I forget which one) with the Apex iron head in 6i. Right off the bat, I was swinging much better and Steve liked the numbers much better than my gamer. It was tough, because I wasn't hitting my gamer as well as I can so I felt it wasn't an ideal comparison, but the numbers didn't lie. Steve then told me that I was swinging a shaft 1/2 inch shorter than standard; he wanted to see if I noticed a difference. I definitely did. After each shaft, we looked at the numbers and dispersion. The dispersion with the Nippon was very vertical, meaning a little sporadic distance wise. Steve wanted to get dispersion much tighter vertically while he was a little more liberal with horizontal dispersion.
I then hit the KBS Tour 90 in regular flex. I have a set of KBS 90's and like them a lot, so was excited to hit them with the Apex. Sure enough, I was hitting the ball much better. I'm fragile soul, so maybe I started feeling more comfortable with Steve, but I was in a groove and was happy I was hitting the ball well. The dispersion with the KBS was good, but ball flight was a little too high.
Then came the Aerotech Steelfiber. This shaft felt really good and the numbers reflected that. I started out the with i80 in regular flex and height came down while distance went up along with a tighter dispersion. Steve wanted to try the i95 because he still wanted the ball flight lower. The numbers with the i95 were good and it was a tough choice, but the i80 was slightly better so we went with that.
Now that the shaft was decided upon, it was time to try different iron heads. The Apex gave me really good numbers, so all of the other iron heads were playing catch up at this point. Next up was the SpeedBlade, as I have a set and Steve thought maybe the new shaft would beef up the numbers. They did not. We then moved on to the Titleist 714 AP1. I hit this club in a GG for an hour on Monday and really liked how it felt and today was the same thing. The numbers were better than the Apex and I felt a little more confident standing over it, so Steve thought we had a winner. We decided to try a few more. I wanted to try the Anser, which was nice; I hit one of the furthest shots, but there were a couple not so good; not enough to dethrone the 714's. He then wanted me to hit the i20's, but actually stopped me after a few shots because the combo just wasn't working. I agreed.
Last but not least, I tried the Mizuno MP H-4. Before I hit this one, Steve noted that we had been going for a while and that if I wanted, we could break up the fitting into a couple sessions if I was getting tired. Based on how I hit the Anser and i20 (read crappy) compared to the other irons, he wanted to make sure fatigue wasn't setting in. I guess that fired me up because I annihilated all 6 shots of the H4 further than any of the others and with airtight dispersion, right in the center. Weight felt great, impact was smooth and sound was terrific. Sound didn't used to affect me, but now it does and these fit the bill perfectly. Steve seemed delighted as I was. We then talked about lie, loft and gapping, as well as how the irons would transition to the wedges. My lie was half a degree upright, which actually was good to hear, as this time last year I was fit 2 degrees flat and my recent lessons have focused on getting a lot more upright.
As for wedges, Steve recommended the Mizuno T-4's in 50, 54 (bent to 55) and 60, with the 50 put in the same shaft as the irons. He feels having the same OEM wedges as irons is important for groove composition and feel. I didn't get to hit them or anything, so will need to try them out before even considering replacing my good old RTX CB's.
We started to get into hybrids, but then decided on doing a separate long game fitting, as he wanted a fresh swing for those numbers, especially since woods seem to take the longest. It is winter here and I haven't been playing for the last month and a half, so that sounded good to me. The only thing I'll say is that of the few hybrid combinations I tried, I'm not sure any were good enough to take the X Hots out of the bag.
We ended with the putter fitting and this was probably the most eye opening for me, as I have never done any type of analysis with my putting. I showed up with two very different putters, my Maranello, which has 90 degrees of toe hang; and a Bettinardi BB33, which is face balanced. I decided to putt with the Betti and right off the bat, Steve noticed a number of problems with my putting. Of course, I made 4 out of 5 putts, so take that, SAM (which is the putter fitting system they use). At any rate, I'm a push putter, just like Ben Crenshaw (good enough for me), which means I have an open stance and putt to the line, not with where my feet are lined up. I was also strangling the grip, so he immediately saw I needed a slightly larger one. I also deloft the putter at impact, which is apparently a good thing. And I stand pretty up right, which gets me off balance, so he shortened my length to 34.5 inches. At the end of the day, he liked about 30 - 45 degrees of toe hang instead of 90 with a 34.5 inch length and a 2.5 Slim grip. I putted with the Scottie Sonoma, which he felt was perfect for me. It felt pretty good, so we shall see about that.
Generally, I found the fitting extremely educational. Steve answered any and all questions I had, explained the reason behind certain equipment selections and really went into a lot of detail with the putter fitting. I thought the wedge "fitting" could have been a little more in depth and there was a little more sales pitching than needed to be, but this fitting was much more detailed and thorough than my last one at another facility. It's certainly one of if not the premier fitting stores in my area and I feel satisfied with two of my main goals going into the fitting; determining an ideal iron shaft/head combination and an ideal putter configuration.
I'm scheduled to go back next week for my woods and hybrids, so I will have more to report. I am wondering whether my hybrid and woods should be shortened half an inch as well, just like my irons were. I really want to get the distance part of my bag dialed in, so I plan on asking a ton of questions and trying out a lot of stuff to get there.
For anyone considering this, I would recommend it. They have a 50% off deal right now, so it felt like a no brainer to me. You learn a lot and what's better than talking about how to improve your game for a few hours with professionals?
Now I need to figure out how to get a set of H4 iron heads and some Steelfiber i80 regular flex shafts. If anyone has spares, just let me know. :act-up:
I showed up with my bag and a few different clubs. I brought a few different irons and a couple putters, as I've been switching between all of them lately and part of the reason I was there was to sort all of this out and figure out what would be ideal.
Let me start off by saying I really enjoyed the fitting immensely. My two main goals relating to irons and putters were more than satisfied. But in all honesty, things didn't start off all that well and I was a little put off during the initial discussion. He wanted to know what I was looking to get out of the fitting. I told him I really wanted to figure out the ideal iron shaft for me, check out some iron heads, and spend a lot of time finding the right hybrid/fairway wood combination for my distance game. He asked what irons I was interested in, I told him Adams CB3, to which he just said, "that's out; they don't even make that any more." Ok then. I think he was annoyed I showed up with a few different irons and he wanted me to commit to one. That was fair enough. He then asked what ball I play, so I told him, and he wanted to know why. I told him my last fitting told me to hit them and I liked them, and he kind of laughed it off, telling me the only way to get the ideal ball was to try them all outside during play (although this was like a 5 minute lecture). It felt like the whole schpiel was to show me how little I knew and ridiculous my past equipment decisions were and that I was lucky I would now be set right. At any rate, it was a little rocky start and I'd be lying if I didn't say I was thinking about bagging the whole thing then and there. Fortunately I didn't and I ended up liking my session with Steve a lot.
I warmed up and sure enough, I got my typical "fitter frenzy," where I forget how to hit a golf ball. This has happened every time I've been fit for irons. I managed to hit enough OK shots for him to get some readings. We then talked a little bit about my swing, my transition and what he was thinking in terms of shafts. He discussed numbers with me, including landing angle, which is essentially how the ball starts descending from its peak. He ideally wanted the ball to gradually rise to its peak, then start falling much steeper. He also talked about spin numbers and explained that spin is my friend to keep the ball in the air. Smash factor, ball speed and others were discussed; I'm still digesting it all, but it was helpful. Specifically, he thought I needed a heavier and stiffer shaft, which was a relief to me, because that's how I've recently felt with my swing has been with my current set. I was to hit 6 balls in each shaft/head combination. We started out with a Nippon shaft in regular flex in steel (I forget which one) with the Apex iron head in 6i. Right off the bat, I was swinging much better and Steve liked the numbers much better than my gamer. It was tough, because I wasn't hitting my gamer as well as I can so I felt it wasn't an ideal comparison, but the numbers didn't lie. Steve then told me that I was swinging a shaft 1/2 inch shorter than standard; he wanted to see if I noticed a difference. I definitely did. After each shaft, we looked at the numbers and dispersion. The dispersion with the Nippon was very vertical, meaning a little sporadic distance wise. Steve wanted to get dispersion much tighter vertically while he was a little more liberal with horizontal dispersion.
I then hit the KBS Tour 90 in regular flex. I have a set of KBS 90's and like them a lot, so was excited to hit them with the Apex. Sure enough, I was hitting the ball much better. I'm fragile soul, so maybe I started feeling more comfortable with Steve, but I was in a groove and was happy I was hitting the ball well. The dispersion with the KBS was good, but ball flight was a little too high.
Then came the Aerotech Steelfiber. This shaft felt really good and the numbers reflected that. I started out the with i80 in regular flex and height came down while distance went up along with a tighter dispersion. Steve wanted to try the i95 because he still wanted the ball flight lower. The numbers with the i95 were good and it was a tough choice, but the i80 was slightly better so we went with that.
Now that the shaft was decided upon, it was time to try different iron heads. The Apex gave me really good numbers, so all of the other iron heads were playing catch up at this point. Next up was the SpeedBlade, as I have a set and Steve thought maybe the new shaft would beef up the numbers. They did not. We then moved on to the Titleist 714 AP1. I hit this club in a GG for an hour on Monday and really liked how it felt and today was the same thing. The numbers were better than the Apex and I felt a little more confident standing over it, so Steve thought we had a winner. We decided to try a few more. I wanted to try the Anser, which was nice; I hit one of the furthest shots, but there were a couple not so good; not enough to dethrone the 714's. He then wanted me to hit the i20's, but actually stopped me after a few shots because the combo just wasn't working. I agreed.
Last but not least, I tried the Mizuno MP H-4. Before I hit this one, Steve noted that we had been going for a while and that if I wanted, we could break up the fitting into a couple sessions if I was getting tired. Based on how I hit the Anser and i20 (read crappy) compared to the other irons, he wanted to make sure fatigue wasn't setting in. I guess that fired me up because I annihilated all 6 shots of the H4 further than any of the others and with airtight dispersion, right in the center. Weight felt great, impact was smooth and sound was terrific. Sound didn't used to affect me, but now it does and these fit the bill perfectly. Steve seemed delighted as I was. We then talked about lie, loft and gapping, as well as how the irons would transition to the wedges. My lie was half a degree upright, which actually was good to hear, as this time last year I was fit 2 degrees flat and my recent lessons have focused on getting a lot more upright.
As for wedges, Steve recommended the Mizuno T-4's in 50, 54 (bent to 55) and 60, with the 50 put in the same shaft as the irons. He feels having the same OEM wedges as irons is important for groove composition and feel. I didn't get to hit them or anything, so will need to try them out before even considering replacing my good old RTX CB's.
We started to get into hybrids, but then decided on doing a separate long game fitting, as he wanted a fresh swing for those numbers, especially since woods seem to take the longest. It is winter here and I haven't been playing for the last month and a half, so that sounded good to me. The only thing I'll say is that of the few hybrid combinations I tried, I'm not sure any were good enough to take the X Hots out of the bag.
We ended with the putter fitting and this was probably the most eye opening for me, as I have never done any type of analysis with my putting. I showed up with two very different putters, my Maranello, which has 90 degrees of toe hang; and a Bettinardi BB33, which is face balanced. I decided to putt with the Betti and right off the bat, Steve noticed a number of problems with my putting. Of course, I made 4 out of 5 putts, so take that, SAM (which is the putter fitting system they use). At any rate, I'm a push putter, just like Ben Crenshaw (good enough for me), which means I have an open stance and putt to the line, not with where my feet are lined up. I was also strangling the grip, so he immediately saw I needed a slightly larger one. I also deloft the putter at impact, which is apparently a good thing. And I stand pretty up right, which gets me off balance, so he shortened my length to 34.5 inches. At the end of the day, he liked about 30 - 45 degrees of toe hang instead of 90 with a 34.5 inch length and a 2.5 Slim grip. I putted with the Scottie Sonoma, which he felt was perfect for me. It felt pretty good, so we shall see about that.
Generally, I found the fitting extremely educational. Steve answered any and all questions I had, explained the reason behind certain equipment selections and really went into a lot of detail with the putter fitting. I thought the wedge "fitting" could have been a little more in depth and there was a little more sales pitching than needed to be, but this fitting was much more detailed and thorough than my last one at another facility. It's certainly one of if not the premier fitting stores in my area and I feel satisfied with two of my main goals going into the fitting; determining an ideal iron shaft/head combination and an ideal putter configuration.
I'm scheduled to go back next week for my woods and hybrids, so I will have more to report. I am wondering whether my hybrid and woods should be shortened half an inch as well, just like my irons were. I really want to get the distance part of my bag dialed in, so I plan on asking a ton of questions and trying out a lot of stuff to get there.
For anyone considering this, I would recommend it. They have a 50% off deal right now, so it felt like a no brainer to me. You learn a lot and what's better than talking about how to improve your game for a few hours with professionals?
Now I need to figure out how to get a set of H4 iron heads and some Steelfiber i80 regular flex shafts. If anyone has spares, just let me know. :act-up:
Last edited: