We've launched the new forums! Read more here

Differences between tour golf and amateur golf players

jefrazie

jefrazie

New member
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
1,476
Reaction score
10
Location
Raleigh, NC
Handicap
13.9 OOB
I have always wondered, what is the difference between some of you low handicappers (1-3) or scratch golfers vs the pros?

I realize that the pro course is longer but if you low 'cappers were to play a tour level course on the tour tees, would it still be possible for you to shoot as low as you normally do?
 
A lot. In every stretch of the imagination.
 
I think most tour players are around a +6 handicap or better. I have heard people say that they can't handle the pressure of being on tour. I have also heard that they have the talent to do it, but not the mental game.
 
Huge difference. The difference between a 0 and a +2 is huge.Same goes for the guys that are a +2 and want to compete against +4's.Such a different level.


Some of the other differences is,Many play the same courses over and over,which help them maintain a lower handicap .

Conditions are never close to tour quality as in speed and firmness of greens and thickness of rough.
 
ummm, a lot of money, private jets, your pick of perkins waitresses, 500k watches, free golf, more perkins waitresses, having your strokes counted by a fatty in a recliner, fast cars, free clubs, unlimited golf balls
 
I've heard it said that the difference between tour pro level and a scratch golfer is bigger than the difference between scratch and a 15 handicap. The old PGA Tour slogan of "These guys are good" was doing them a dis-service. They aren't good. They are unreal. Impossibly good. Gooder than good. Should have been "These guys are frickin' unbelievable" or something.
 
They have an army of people behind them. If any one of us had there caddy for a round we would see our score drop. There caddys do most of the thinking for them. Then it's a coach for every club and swing. This includes the putting coach and short game coach. Not to mention there sports psyc there with them. I had a 4 day pass to last years Barclay and it turned me around from what i thought. They are not gods of golf that for sure. Not what they seem to be on TV or in mags.

They are good for sure. They have to step up and hit the ball the way there caddys suggests them too. They don't always follow it and it shows. Lots of mis hits,slices,hooks etc.

Put that army of people behind any one of us for a year and we could be there too imo.
 
Penglynns said:
I've heard it said that the difference between tour pro level and a scratch golfer is bigger than the difference between scratch and a 15 handicap. The old PGA Tour slogan of "These guys are good" was doing them a dis-service. They aren't good. They are unreal. Impossibly good. Gooder than good. Should have been "These guys are frickin' unbelievable" or something.
Click to expand...

So what would a scratch golfer or +1 have to do to really make a push for the pros? Just curious about how you recognize that you are good enough to play with the big boys.
 
The 2 best golfers I personally know will tell you it is putting, both were small college All-Americans and spent several years playing the mini tours. They both say that their putting held them back. One of them is the best putter I personally know too, so it is unreal how important it is among the great ball strikers. All you have to do it look at TW's putting after all of his escapades and see what they mean.
 
ezrider said:
They have an army of people behind them. If any one of us had there caddy for a round we would see our score drop. There caddys do most of the thinking for them. Then it's a coach for every club and swing. This includes the putting coach and short game coach. Not to mention there sports psyc there with them. I had a 4 day pass to last years Barclay and it turned me around from what i thought. They are not gods of golf that for sure. Not what they seem to be on TV or in mags.

They are good for sure. They have to step up and hit the ball the way there caddys suggests them too. They don't always follow it and it shows. Lots of mis hits,slices,hooks etc.

Put that army of people behind any one of us for a year and we could be there too imo.
Click to expand...

You couldn't be more wrong. IMHO.
 
My instructor is a +2 and has been a +3. He is the best I have ever played with, he has played some on the Asia tour, and has made a living playing professionally. He tells me he isn't even close to PGA tour level, mostly due to his length. The holes are so long on tour now and average par 3 is well over 200 yards and and average par 4 is 450. To be a PGA pro you have to have unbelievable talent, good to great length, a short game that makes any 40 yard shot look easy, and putt lights out, all under more pressure than you can imagine. Very few can do it.
 
DawgDaddy said:
The 2 best golfers I personally know will tell you it is putting, both were small college All-Americans and spent several years playing the mini tours. They both say that their putting held them back. One of them is the best putter I personally know too, so it is unreal how important it is among the great ball strikers. All you have to do it look at TW's putting after all of his escapades and see what they mean.
Click to expand...

+1. I also think the ability to practice daily is a big help. I feel that my game would be that much better if I could get in 200 swings a day plus short game work.
 
tomahawk18 said:
My instructor is a +2 and has been a +3. He is the best I have ever played with, he has played some on the Asia tour, and has made a living playing professionally. He tells me he isn't even close to PGA tour level, mostly due to his length. The holes are so long on tour now and average par 3 is well over 200 yards and and average par 4 is 450. To be a PGA pro you have to have unbelievable talent, good to great length, a short game that makes any 40 yard shot look easy, and putt lights out, all under more pressure than you can imagine. Very few can do it.
Click to expand...

I agree that they have to have amazing talent but the equipment they have access to will also help some. The golf balls they use are hotter than any ball we can buy off a shelf. That's not a major reason but it is still an advantage.
 
One-T said:
ummm, a lot of money, private jets, your pick of perkins waitresses, 500k watches, free golf, more perkins waitresses, having your strokes counted by a fatty in a recliner, fast cars, free clubs, unlimited golf balls
Click to expand...

I've seen a +2hdcp snag a Perkins waitress in my time...it might have been the ole beat up, 40+ -pall-mall-smoking-hairs-lost-in-the-80s'-drives-a-trans-am-and -has a side-job-cutting-hair-in-her-basement-waitress....but a perkins waitress none the less.
 
There's a book out there called Paper Tiger, which is about a guy who spent a year trying to go from low handicapper to pro golfer by hiring a personal trainer, swing coach, sports psychologist. He failed miserably. I haven't read it, but my buddy says its a great read.

Also, I used to play with a guy who used to play on the Hooters tour back in the day (pre Nike/Nationwide tour). He's a +2 and said he got his butt handed to him. He said shooting 68-70 wasn't good enough to compete on the Hooters tour (courses aren't nearly as demanding as PGA tour stops).

My 2 cents, not only are there differences in the short game, but tour pros hit just about everything to inside 20 feet, include long irons. I can hit it out there 280-330 just like they can, but a tour pro expects to hit a certain section of the fairway so they can attack the pin, and I am happy when my ball just finds the short grass!
 
Mardin said:
I've seen a +2hdcp snag a Perkins waitress in my time...it might have been the ole beat up, 40+ -pall-mall-smoking-hairs-lost-in-the-80s'-drives-a-trans-am-and -has a side-job-cutting-hair-in-her-basement-waitress....but a perkins waitress none the less.
Click to expand...

Hahahaheheheheeeeeeewwwwww....
 
One-T said:
ummm, a lot of money, private jets, your pick of perkins waitresses, 500k watches, free golf, more perkins waitresses, having your strokes counted by a fatty in a recliner, fast cars, free clubs, unlimited golf balls
Click to expand...

Good stuff One-t.... good stuff!!
 
I've played with a few 0 - +2 handicappers and they hit the ball fairly long off the tee, but it was around the green that made a world of difference. Putting is a different ball game for the one's at that level and I'm sure at the pga pro level it's several steps beyond!!
 
In an edition of Golf Magazine a few months back (Sept. 2010 - NFL'ers who love golf) it had an article about football players who thought that they could join a pro tour when they retired from the NFL. Jerry Rice was the main focus of the article, but it highlighted several other players who all were either scratch golfers or better. It basically detailed how they were all major failures on the tours they joined, whether it was the Nationwide or Senior tours.

These guys who carry a +2 hcp were shooting in the mid 80's on the Nationwide tour. They admitted that even the Nationwide pros have unreal talent when compared to your local club champion. Fairways are much tighter, greens are much faster, and the pressure of having a gallery surround you on every shot is just something that you can't prepare for when you're going low on a Sunday afternoon with your buddies.

Billy Joe Tolliver said:
“If you’re not beating the best players in your club every day,” he adds, “and you’re not shooting 68 or better every single day, don’t waste your time. The average person out there has no idea how good Nationwide Tour players are.”
Click to expand...

Mark Rypien said:
“When we play golf with our buddies in our own little world, the atmosphere is a lot easier, simpler and less stressful,” says Rypien, now 47 and living in his hometown of Spokane, Wash. “The setup of the course [on Tour] is incredible -- you don’t appreciate that as much watching on TV as you do standing on the tee box trying to make par.

“And the skill set [difference] is glaring. There’s a small gap between the best players in golf and guys on mini-tours -- and a large gap between those players and us.”
Click to expand...
 
I watched a guy shoot a -4 on a 73/133 course who told me he couldn't make it on the Hooters tour. Dunno if that means anything. Was his first time there also.
 
I would say like the difference between a +2 handicap and a 36 handicap golfer.
 
I think on Twitter the other day Hank Haney said an amateur would need to practice everyday for more than a year for atleast 12 hours a day to make it to the tour....something like that. The courses we hack around at, pros would seriously shred them, Tiger once played with just his 4 iron and shot 76, most people have never broken 80 with all 14 clubs and mulligans, most guys will never legitimately break 80 in their entire life, I think Vijay can break 80 left handed. They are good.
 
jefrazie said:
I have always wondered, what is the difference between some of you low handicappers (1-3) or scratch golfers vs the pros?

I realize that the pro course is longer but if you low 'cappers were to play a tour level course on the tour tees, would it still be possible for you to shoot as low as you normally do?
Click to expand...

Not a chance in most cases.

Just consider that there are about 25 million golfers, and declining in number in the US and about 35 million golfers or more in the world. Professional golfer's make up less than 0.001% of this total.
These people are "world class" players and play a game the rest of us do not know. I would doubt that hardly any low cappers could play to their index at a tour course in tournament setup.
 
Bah. It's not that tough to play on tour. I could have done it when I was younger.

I just didn't feel like it.

Kevin
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top