OK...so our club's 2-man best-ball match play semi-final match was today and it got ugly before it got started and I will try to keep this brief. This is an 80% handicap event...very important.
First the stats:
Me a 16
My teammate a +3
Their player A was a 2
Their player B was an 8
They get to the first tee and we see that the computer generated scorecard had ink all over it changing my teammates handicap and adding extra holes with strokes for their team. We questioned this and they stated that they explained to the clubhouse that the computer was wrong and that his handicap should not come back towards 0 like everyone else and should continue going further from 0 in the positive direction. We called the clubhouse and they would not listen to our case and said that it was wrong for the first three rounds because the computer does not "properly adjust" for a positive hcp.
We said what-ever and were not happy...my teammate said something to the nature of "ok, if you guys can playing knowing you are getting more then the rules should be"...and their player B blew at at that statement. He pointed his finger in his face and said that we were "tainting the match at the start and insinuating that they were intentionally being dishonest". He felt the need to go on and tell us how "honest" they are, and that his teammate was known to be "the most honest player at the club". We started play after getting things under control and you could cut the tension in the match with a dull golf ball.
They were 3 up after 11 and on the 12th hole the pro comes driving to the fairway and gets us all together and says "sorry guys, we have never had a + player in an 80% event and what the other team explained to him made sense and he went with it. He said after we questioned it it got his thinking and he looked up the rule from the USGA and found that my teammate was correct.
Here is where it gets even more angering from out standpoint. Right away my teammate and I said "dead-day, we have to play it over another day". They said no, lets just go back and adjust where needed and play it out. (side not...the 8 hcp was a -3 at this point in the round!!!!) It would have changed the score for 1 hole that we would have won instead of a half. So they said "we are just 2up instead of 3up and play on". We said BS...if we win 6 we walk off that green having won 5 and 6 and are Square instead of 1 down and chasing them. Plus...the mindset of my teammate was not great considering the situation and that the match was played under the wrong pretenses. Since we would not agree...the pro thought about it for a little while and finally said that it needed to be replayed.
We finished like this...we played out 12-18, clearly with less pressure but with even more tension.
Me 90 (74 net)
My teammate 69 (72 net)
Their A player 69 (67 net)
Their B player 71 (63 net)
Very angering situation.
First the stats:
Me a 16
My teammate a +3
Their player A was a 2
Their player B was an 8
They get to the first tee and we see that the computer generated scorecard had ink all over it changing my teammates handicap and adding extra holes with strokes for their team. We questioned this and they stated that they explained to the clubhouse that the computer was wrong and that his handicap should not come back towards 0 like everyone else and should continue going further from 0 in the positive direction. We called the clubhouse and they would not listen to our case and said that it was wrong for the first three rounds because the computer does not "properly adjust" for a positive hcp.
We said what-ever and were not happy...my teammate said something to the nature of "ok, if you guys can playing knowing you are getting more then the rules should be"...and their player B blew at at that statement. He pointed his finger in his face and said that we were "tainting the match at the start and insinuating that they were intentionally being dishonest". He felt the need to go on and tell us how "honest" they are, and that his teammate was known to be "the most honest player at the club". We started play after getting things under control and you could cut the tension in the match with a dull golf ball.
They were 3 up after 11 and on the 12th hole the pro comes driving to the fairway and gets us all together and says "sorry guys, we have never had a + player in an 80% event and what the other team explained to him made sense and he went with it. He said after we questioned it it got his thinking and he looked up the rule from the USGA and found that my teammate was correct.
Here is where it gets even more angering from out standpoint. Right away my teammate and I said "dead-day, we have to play it over another day". They said no, lets just go back and adjust where needed and play it out. (side not...the 8 hcp was a -3 at this point in the round!!!!) It would have changed the score for 1 hole that we would have won instead of a half. So they said "we are just 2up instead of 3up and play on". We said BS...if we win 6 we walk off that green having won 5 and 6 and are Square instead of 1 down and chasing them. Plus...the mindset of my teammate was not great considering the situation and that the match was played under the wrong pretenses. Since we would not agree...the pro thought about it for a little while and finally said that it needed to be replayed.
We finished like this...we played out 12-18, clearly with less pressure but with even more tension.
Me 90 (74 net)
My teammate 69 (72 net)
Their A player 69 (67 net)
Their B player 71 (63 net)
Very angering situation.
Last edited: