- Thread starter
- Admin
- #101
Haha at Goat…
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature currently requires accessing the site using the built-in Safari browser.
Are you saying Rodgers is the GOAT?I'm a Packers fan AND a Rodgers fan, even this week. Been watching since early 1970s.
Where on earth are these Saints fans getting the idea Rodgers was playing on loaded teams? LMFAO. The Packers have won the past 10 years because Rodgers outscored the other team's offense. It sure wasn't because of the defense, especially the coordinators. The worst thing that happened to the Packers long term was winning the 2011 Super Bowl because they thought they could skate by with Dom Capers bend-don't break defensive schemes. I have NEVER seen a team give up more 3rd and long first downs than the Packers defenses the past decade.
And, the offense? O-line has been good, and paid accordingly to protect the GOAT. But, I agreed with Ed Werder, when on ESPN radio prior to last season, said on any other NFL team, Davante Adams would be a "really good #2 wide receiver." The only reason Adams rises above the rest is he runs routes really well. But, that's ALL he does. He doesn't read defenses and doesn't break off routes when Rodgers has to improvise.
Brees has my respect. But, any numbers better than Rodgers are purely due to four more years in the league. This thread should be closed at the mere mention of all-time QB rating, where Rodgers is better than Brees by five points, 103.9 to 98.7.
Are you saying Rodgers is the GOAT?
Your Joking right?
If you have to debate who's better Rodgers or Brees then Rodgers isn't the GOAT!
Sent from my SM-G998U1 using Tapatalk
This throw is absolutly fricking amazing. Drew Brees never had this in his arsenal. Not saying that makes AR a better QB, just saying. Blows my mind how perfect this throw had to be, not to mention while rolling to the left...and against the Cowboys in the playoffs, so money. If someone asked me what the best pass I ever saw was, I would say this one.
You missed that whole thread a year or so ago. I asked who the 2nd best qb of the last 20 years was and lots said Brady!Wait now we have people arguing rodgers > brady?
This whole thread has become a laughable Packers ️ Jerk...
To take the stance that Rodgers is better than Brees is perfectly fine, but to act like Rodgers is elite & Brees is a scrub is just egregious.
Because it appears that Packers fans don’t watch a lot of games with teams other than their own, here are some Brees highlights.
During the course of their careers the NFC South has been the way more competitive division than the NFC North. This is a fact and it’s not in dispute. In the last 10 years, every single organization in the NFC South has played in the Super Bowl.
This debate is very close, to act other wise is short sided.
Brees has my respect. But, any numbers better than Rodgers are purely due to four more years in the league. This thread should be closed at the mere mention of all-time QB rating, where Rodgers is better than Brees by five points, 103.9 to 98.7.
As a Pats fan, I understand your love and focus on all things Patriots. What sets Packers fans apart is we are actually fans of the NFL. I'll say this again, because you apparently didn't pick up on what I said in the post you responded to.
Aaron Rodgers has put an entire team on his back for over 10 years, playing at a level that is truly remarkable. Brady has had franchise support on both sides of the ball. And, to stick a fork in this conversation, the same way the fork was stuck in the Rodgers vs Brees argument: Rodgers all-time passer rating is 103.9 while Brady is 97.3.
Rodgers is the GOAT. Period.
Sorry about being a Raiders fan... woofMissed the mark here. Bay Area born and raised Raider fan here. Couldn't give two shats about the Packers...Just offering an amazing highlight to the thread. So sorry it wasn't a Dwewyyy Bweeezyyyy highlight.
Rodgers isn’t in the same tier as Brady & Manning... He’s not even better than Brees & Brees is in the tier below Manning & Brady.I get the love of a fan. Hell ask just about anyone here about my support of Wentz. But, do you really think Rodgers is throwing over 30,000 yards and 160 Tds in just 4 years? Even in this pass happy league now, Rodgers isn’t getting close to those numbers.
Not to take this thread in another direction, but comparing Rodgers as better than Brady is laughable after this year.
7 to 1 is all that needs to be said.
7
Sorry about being a Raiders fan... woof
Rodgers isn’t in the same tier as Brady & Manning... He’s not even better than Brees & Brees is in the tier below Manning & Brady.
Ok I’m good with this list...
I am a fan of the NFL not just the Patriots have been for 40+ years.As a Pats fan, I understand your love and focus on all things Patriots. What sets Packers fans apart is we are actually fans of the NFL. I'll say this again, because you apparently didn't pick up on what I said in the post you responded to.
Aaron Rodgers has put an entire team on his back for over 10 years, playing at a level that is truly remarkable. Brady has had franchise support on both sides of the ball. And, to stick a fork in this conversation, the same way the fork was stuck in the Rodgers vs Brees argument: Rodgers all-time passer rating is 103.9 while Brady is 97.3.
Rodgers is the GOAT. Period.
I’m not a Patriots fan.Wow. A bunch of butt hurt Patriots fans here...
Here, to put my view of Brady in perspective, he’s definitely top 10 in a tier with the late Bart Starr. I argue Brady is the modern version of Bart Starr.
I get New England has only been around since 1960. So their fan base doesn’t have historical perspective. But Bart Starr was a game manager the way Vince Lombardi wanted. And Starr always had great defenses to support him. Great coach, great support on both sides of the ball. Sound familiar Pats fans? Brady is the modern Bart Starr...
Weird how you glossed over the Toy Romo one…Using QBR as your dynamic trait of best ever says all it needs too.An honest assessment of Chad Pennington's QBR would include a caveat that states that while he played 11 seasons, in five of those seasons, he played in three games or less. It would also include a caveat he only played 89 games total over his career. Favre played over 300...
If Pennington's your poster child for QBR, this discussion is over. I have no desire preaching to the perverted...