One pie to rule them all

[camden_kid]

Which pie is the greatest of all?

You can choose any food item that you consider to be a "pie". Sweet or non-sweet, doesn't matter. Just has to be a pie.

 

[Jman]

Pecan.

It’ll always be atop the mountain for me.

 

[echico]

Strawberry rhubarb

 

[Sox_Fan]

Cheesecake. Yes, I am that guy that thinks it is a pie rather than a cake based on the looks and consistency of the finished product.

 

[gkeller813]

Strawberry

 

[Bus]

Strawberry rubharb

 

[YukonLiving]

Sweet - Apple. It’s the quintessential.

Savoury - Mince and Cheese.

 

[camden_kid]

Steak and kidney pie.

 

[DataDude]

Butterscotch cream pie for me.

 

[War Eagle]

Pecan, easy choice.

A variation my grandmother would make was a chocolate chip pecan pie, which was almost as amazing.

 

[BH 43]

Warm apple pie and ice cream.

 

[Templet0n]

Banana cream or sweet potato

 

[Slowmo]

If I can cheat and say that peach cobbler is a pie then that’s my choice by a large margin. If not then my grandma’s chocolate pie.

 

[AuzzieMatt]

I have to choose two, one savory and one sweet.

Savory, Aussie meat pie and it ain't close at all.



Sweet, coconut cream pie.

 

[MacTourney]

Achatz 4-Berry Pie, handmade and Mitten sourced. If you're ever in SE Michigan do yourself a favor.

Michigan 4-Berry ® | Achatz Handmade Pies

Our signature and best selling pie. Michigan tart cherries, blackberries, blueberries, and raspberries with our traditional crumb topping.

www.achatzpies.com

 

[AuzzieMatt]

Steak and kidney pie.

That's a really good one. Love a steak and kidney almost as much as an Aussie meat pie.

 

[Slowmo]

I have to choose two, one savory and one sweet.

Savory, Aussie meat pie and it ain't close at all.

View attachment 9229147

Sweet, coconut cream pie.

View attachment 9229148

Gotta admit, that meat pie looks tasty

 

[1860VS]

Rhubarb. Not too sweet. Nothing beats rhubarb.

 

[WLG1952]

My Wife makes a Cheese Cake pie with a Pecan pie topping on it. Her's is the only one I've ever seen offered.

She has won a few awards in competitions.

She has made them for our Daughters, and Grand Kids charity bake sales. They always make top dollar.

No other pie compares to these delights.

 

[CBaker]

Trick question, and the answer is pizza.

 

[That post]

Pizza pie.

 

[Parrot]

Key Lime.

 

[Outthere]

Shepard’s pie

 

[Junkyard]

If permissible I must go with cheese cake.

If not then lemon meringue.

 

[milehighgolfer]

Sweet potato pecan pie. All the goodness of both in one .