JPsuff
Banned
this certainly has been an entertaining read....thanks to all for putting their opinions out there and thanks to JP for helping with my word of the day!
so here's my opinion on the last few pages of banter:
seem as though JP finds walkers to be more serious golfers. i prefer to walk if i can, it's just my cup of tea, does it make me any more serious about my game on that particular day? nope! i tend to take my game seriously whether i'm riding, walking, playing in spiring, fall, winter or summer. i'm still not sure if i'm a serious golfer in his book, but then again i really don't care.
i also want to say that i find JP's perspective on things interesting and refreshing for the most part, but i have to say that i believe your stance here is way too extreme. i hate to be the one to tell you but living in the mountains, it's just not feasible to walk many of the courses. they tend to build courses around here that offer spectacular views so most courses are cut on ridge, on the sides of ridges and peaks and it would be virtually impossible to walk. i also find your comments about blades and GI irons offensive. i'm glad you can go out and hit blades, mishit them, but at least know that you mishit them. guess what? i know when i mishit my GI irons, you want to know how? b/c i take my game serioulsy and i've put in a lot of hard work and time on my game. it pains me to say this but it's b/c of golfers like you that i don't post my hcp here (at least my real one). i feel that you would be far too judgemental about what's in my bag, how thick my toplines are, and how huge my shovels are compared to quality of golfer that i happen to be.
i know that you have your opinions, your beliefs, your customs and your ways concerning this game and i can respect that, but it's a completely biased view. you've put yourself up on a pedestal and i have a feeling that you didn't want to, but that's just the way that it comes across.
Good post, TC. Lots of good points and some things to think about, so here's what I think:
this certainly has been an entertaining read....thanks to all for putting their opinions out there and thanks to JP for helping with my word of the day!
No problem, glad I could help!
so here's my opinion on the last few pages of banter:seem as though JP finds walkers to be more serious golfers. i prefer to walk if i can, it's just my cup of tea, does it make me any more serious about my game on that particular day? nope! i tend to take my game seriously whether i'm riding, walking, playing in spiring, fall, winter or summer.
Not quite.
When I wrote what I wrote, I knew that it was going to be misunderstood but I assumed that subsequent posts would be able to clear it up. That obviously didn’t happen and things have come to the point where many are assuming that I said that riders are not serious golfers and that is not what I wrote.
What I wrote was: “walkers as a group tend to take the game more seriously than riders overall”
This was perhaps an unfortunate choice of words but the key word is “overall”. What I meant by this statement was simply this: Both Walkers and Riders can claim serious golfers in their ranks. But those who aren’t serious or who are not “there just to play golf” tend to take carts more often than choosing to walk, therefore walkers tend to be more serious than riders overall.
Most people who play golf for reasons other than “serious reasons”; for example to hang out and party with their friends, to kill an afternoon doing something different, to try golf for the hell of it, the “Happy Gilmore” types, the once or twice a year “outings”, the “never tried it before” types and so on, more often than not tend to take to the course in carts rather than on foot because most such casual players can’t see any real fun in walking for almost five miles.
Conversely, people who don’t mind such a walk tend to be there because they really want to do this “golf thing” and are – by extension – more serious about playing golf for the sake of golf and not for all of the other reasons.
But that in no way (or at least in no intended way) means that there are no serious golfers who ride in carts. Hell, one of the best golf buddies (and best golfers) I ever played with was primarily a cart guy and I was right there riding along with him when he felt like taking a cart. It’s just that carts are attractive to “everyone else” as well and that (for better or worse) skews the number of “non-serious” players into the ranks of cart-users. So when I look at the overall population of cart-users, I tend to see more “non-serious” people there than I do pulling or carrying a golf bag.
Do you understand what I’m saying?
i also find your comments about blades and GI irons offensive. i'm glad you can go out and hit blades, mishit them, but at least know that you mishit them. guess what? i know when i mishit my GI irons, you want to know how? b/c i take my game serioulsy and i've put in a lot of hard work and time on my game. it pains me to say this but it's b/c of golfers like you that i don't post my hcp here (at least my real one). i feel that you would be far too judgemental about what's in my bag, how thick my toplines are, and how huge my shovels are compared to quality of golfer that i happen to be.
That’s the second time that some has claimed to be “offended” by my comments about blades. What is there to be offended about? I happen to like blades over GI clubs because I see a certain “virtuoso” aspect to them and that’s my opinion (See “Word of the day”, Post #176). If you liked the color red and I didn’t, would you be offended? On the other hand if I said something like: “People who play GI clubs are idiots”, NOW you should be offended, but of course I said no such thing.
I have an affinity for blades because when I was introduced to golf in 1968 that’s all there was. So either you could hit blades or you went bowling (and when I was learning there was often no difference between the two, but that’s another story).
As far as my being judgmental, maybe you’re right, I do tend to get that way sometimes. But isn’t that just another way of saying that I have my own opinions about things? As far as what’s in someone’s golf bag goes, I’m sorry to disappoint you, but I really couldn’t care less. You play the clubs you like and I play the ones I like and that’s the end of it. But you sound as if you think that if I was paired with someone who wasn’t carrying blades that I’d ask the starter to move me to a different group and that’s ridiculous.
i know that you have your opinions, your beliefs, your customs and your ways concerning this game and i can respect that, but it's a completely biased view. you've put yourself up on a pedestal and i have a feeling that you didn't want to, but that's just the way that it comes across.
Well if it wasn’t biased, then it wouldn’t be an opinion, would it?
As for the pedestal, perhaps I sometimes build one now and then, but I find that most of the time people tend to build one for me and I really can't see why. I suppose I should be flattered, but is what I have to say really all that important? I’m just one of millions of people on the ‘net who has an opinion and we all know what they say about opinions. But if someone wants to take issue with something I've written, I’m totally down for that.
It’s a great way to break up an otherwise boring day. :thumb:
-JP