Who's the better player in their prime, with equal equipment?
I watched both play and would definitely say Jack was the better player. You give him the same equipment and data that Tiger had the benefit of and Jack gets the better of Tiger the majority of the time.
I would say they were easily the two best players in my lifetime. But Jack is a level above. I would also add that Jack faced better competition, and still won more majors.
That's my opinion (and it is just an opinion!), so what's yours? This isn't "who's the best player of all time" but just between these two.
I watched both play and would definitely say Jack was the better player. You give him the same equipment and data that Tiger had the benefit of and Jack gets the better of Tiger the majority of the time.
I would say they were easily the two best players in my lifetime. But Jack is a level above. I would also add that Jack faced better competition, and still won more majors.
That's my opinion (and it is just an opinion!), so what's yours? This isn't "who's the best player of all time" but just between these two.