We've launched the new forums! Read more here

your MLB teams hall of fame locks

AndyL0711

AndyL0711

I Need To Play Some Golf!!!!
Albatross 2024 Club
Joined
Dec 13, 2018
Messages
14,909
Reaction score
11,601
Location
Pittsburgh, Pa
Handicap
18
so who do you think, on your favorite MLB team, is a lock for the hall of fame. you can say anyone you want but i would think they have to be in the league a min of 10 years to at least qualify.

for the Phillies i have:
Bryce Harper- 2 x MVP
JT Relamuto- one of, if not, the best catcher in the last 10 years
Craig Kimbrel- not really a Phillie but he is a lock for the hall and is on the Phillies right now.

besides those 3 i really don't see much else. maybe turner could go but he has to play at least 7 or 8 years at a high level. no way any of our other pitchers will go.
 
Joey Votto
 
I think the Braves have a handful on their current roster that definitely have the potential, but most havent hit the 10 year mark.
 
clayton-kershaw-dodgers.giflos-angeles-dodgers-mookie-betts.gifdodgers-freddie-freeman.gifwill-smith-dodgers.gif
 
Michael Lorenzen. ******* legend.
 
is this a if their career ended today kind of thing? If so...nobody on the Yankees
 
AndyL0711 said:
who's the last guy? the first 3 are all in.
Click to expand...
Will Smith... Catcher. He will need some more years but he's on pace at that position.
 
Lock: Verlander
Almost certainly: Altuve

There is a good chance for some of the youngsters, but too soon to throw out the "lock" for them.
 
Last edited:
ddec said:
is this a if their career ended today kind of thing? If so...nobody on the Yankees
Click to expand...
kinda sorta yes.....but i guess if harper had a career ending injury he might not make the hall, it would be close. JT would and Kimbrel would but maybe not harper.
 
For the Cardinals - Goldschmidt and Aranado. I would have put wainwright there too, but he’s struggling to get to 200 wins and he’s not a Yankee, Dodger, or Red Sox player so there is no chance.
 
bigbov said:
Yup... Idk if Smith is a lock but the other 3 should be.
Click to expand...
I have faith. That guy is something and young. If he can keep up this pace for another 7-8 years, I think he has a good shot.
 
Jank said:
Lock: Verlander
Almost certainly: Altuve

There is a good chance for some of the youngsters, but too soon to through out the "lock" for them.
Click to expand...
I’d agree with both these names but I really do think Altuve should be a lock
 
Bryndom said:
I’d agree with both these names but I really do think Altuve should be a lock
Click to expand...

I completely agree, but who knows how MLB will look back on the scandal?
 
Jank said:
Lock: Verlander
Almost certainly: Altuve

There is a good chance for some of the youngsters, but too soon to through out the "lock" for them.
Click to expand...
Tucker is looking like he wants to join this conversation in a few years. Dudes on fire.
 
AndyL0711 said:
so who do you think, on your favorite MLB team, is a lock for the hall of fame. you can say anyone you want but i would think they have to be in the league a min of 10 years to at least qualify.

for the Phillies i have:
Bryce Harper- 2 x MVP
JT Relamuto- one of, if not, the best catcher in the last 10 years
Craig Kimbrel- not really a Phillie but he is a lock for the hall and is on the Phillies right now.

besides those 3 i really don't see much else. maybe turner could go but he has to play at least 7 or 8 years at a high level. no way any of our other pitchers will go.
Click to expand...
I wouldn't say Kimbrel is a lock. Billy Wagner has very similar numbers and isn't in the HOF
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top