I hit my 815 DBD better than the new GBB. For me the look of a club at address certainly has something to do with how well I hit it. The mind is a powerful thing, especially in golf.
I feel a little heretical posting this query given the enthusiasm for the GBB, but what the heck.
I've not playing at all for a few years due to a new child and beer.
So in a blatant attempt to get my fat arse off the couch and slim it down by getting me back onto the golf course, my honey bunny bought me a brand spanking new Big Bertha Alpha(2014 version) for Christmas.
I suspect she was swayed by the massive discount from the golf shop. I'm in Australia and it was $499, now $199!
In any case, she was undoubtedly unaware that the Alpha is for 'better' golfers, and that I am not one of those mythical beasts.
But to humour her, I took it out on the range to compare the hooks I'd hit with it to those I hit with my long term left-side companion, the R7 Superquad (made more expensive by it's trendy at the time Matrix shaft).
To my consternation, I hit the Alpha notably better than the R7.
Somewhat longer, somewhat higher, somewhat less left.
I also loved the sound and feel.
Enthused by this, I got back into reading golf forums, especially this one, and learned that the new Great Big Berthawas even betterer! More forgiving, more longer, more unspinny, more higher launching. More more!
So of course I bought one. Well, two actually with different shafts and lofts.
But now, to even more consternation, I find that I hit the unforgiving obsolete Alpha better than the shiny new (albeit used) GBBs.
The GBB feels too light, too 'flighty' and too lefty.
I'm obviously in the minority, but am I alone in this?
Lofts are the same at 10.5. Shafts are the stock Fubuki ZT reg in the Alpha and the Kuro stiff in the GBB. Swing speed is high 90s and I can get a bit aggressive.
It may be a weight thing as I'm a big lad and do like the feel of a weightier club and GBB feels much lighter.
In the GBB's defence, this is based on a few (long) range sessions, with crappy balls. I haven't explored launch monitors yet.