The $1000 Challenge

JB

Follow @THPGolf on Social Media
Albatross 2024 Club
Staff member
Joined
Oct 8, 2008
Messages
283,973
Reaction score
436,946
Location
THP Experiences
I followed this for a while and it was pretty interesting. Now obviously everybody's financial situation is different, but do you think you could cut your budget dramatically each month?

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/could-cut-spending-1-000-145150037.html

As a newspaper columnist in Detroit, Brian J. O'Connor didn't feel like he had much job security. "My paper had been sold, which automatically makes everybody nervous, and clearly Detroit was not doing well," O'Connor says of the bleak period in October 2009 when he launched his money-saving experiment.

That experiment involved cutting $1,000 a month from his budget, largely by focusing on recurring expenses. "Partly I wanted to fail as much as succeed because I wanted to illustrate how tough it can be if you really have to make big cuts in a family budget," O'Connor, 53, says. If parents went to work in the morning and came home unemployed, or suddenly lost overtime pay - as many workers did in Detroit during the recession - then they similarly needed to immediately transform their spending in order to stay afloat, he says.

His series of humorous columns on the experiment were so popular that he turned them into a book, "The $1,000 Challenge: How One Family Slashed Its Budget Without Moving Under a Bridge or Living on Government Cheese," which will be released this week.

Trimming $1,000 a month, which he managed to do, might sound overly ambitious, but O'Connor says that's the point. "It had to be a high-wire act, or there'd be nothing at stake," he says, adding that even cutting a grand each month wouldn't be enough for him, his wife and his son to survive if he suddenly lost his job. Still, it would be a start.

Ready to replicate O'Connor's strategy? Here are five categories where you're most likely to gin up some serious savings.

1. Phone, cable and Internet
"The easiest savings I got was cutting the utilities," O'Connor says. After spending an afternoon making a handful of calls to his cable, phone and Internet provider, he slimmed down his bundle of charges by about $140 per month. Part of that was removing services he didn't need, such as a $15 monthly charge that allowed him to use his cellphone as a modem (he forgot to cancel that service after a vacation), and a third-party voice messaging service on his home phone.

He trimmed down his cable service to a 200 channel package, which generated about $30 in savings. When he similarly downgraded his Internet service based on the amount of data his family actually used, the provider rebated him for the previous two months, since he had been paying for a more expensive data plan than he needed.

The total savings came to $140 a month plus $653.80 in refunds, temporary discounts and a $200 gift card. "That's more than a month's worth of groceries plus ongoing savings for just a couple hours on the phone," O'Connor says.

"Some of it was just dumb, which is a recurring theme in the book," O'Connor says. In other words, if he had paid attention to his bills, he would have had the charges removed long ago. But it's easy to never get around to it, or to overlook those superfluous expenses. That's why O'Connor recommends taking a close look at every household bill once a month, so you can eliminate the services you don't even realize you're paying for.

2. Unusual expenses
Do you have an oddball expense that's eating away at your bank account each month? For some people, it might be an expensive hobby; for O'Connor, it was his 30-year-old boat. It was costing him several hundred dollars in repairs some months. He saved almost $100 a month by creating a separate annual fund that served as a cushion for boat-related expenses, instead of scrambling to come up with the money whenever something broke.

3. Child care
If your employer offers flexible spending accounts, you can set aside pre-tax dollars to pay for health care, child care and commuting costs, up to certain limits. O'Connor saved more than $100 a month by paying for his son's speech therapy through a flexible health spending account. He points out that for two working parents, taking advantage of child care flexible spending accounts can also make a big dent in monthly expenses.

4. Home
Refinancing when interest rates are low can help reduce monthly mortgage payments. When O'Connor refinanced, he opted to slightly increase his monthly payment so he could switch to a 15-year mortgage and make sure his home was paid off prior to retirement. For monthly savings, O'Connor drilled into his home maintenance spending. He cut $60 a month by stopping maid service and an extra $10 from regular home maintenance.

5. Groceries
Food shopping is an area ripe for savings, since it's easy to overspend on name-brand pasta sauce, organic apples and prepared meals. O'Connor invested some time into comparison shopping and coupon hunting - on his first trip under his new regime, he spent 2.5 hours at the grocery store -- but it paid off. "You spend 10 minutes walking up and down the frozen meat aisle looking for the special on frozen turkey breast," he says.

Subsequent trips, though, did not take nearly as long because he developed his system (and gained familiarity with the store's placements). He saved about $40 for the month, and he didn't feel like he was sacrificing much. "Store-brand tomatoes don't feel any different to me than premium," he says.

Still, it's hard to spend the time to maximize deals every week, O'Connor acknowledges, especially with two working parents. He and his wife have to skip their coupon-maximizing efforts some weeks, especially when one of them is traveling for work.

The biggest takeaway from O'Connor's $1,000 challenge is to focus on recurring expenses, because when you cut them once, you keep them off the books the following months, too. So if you do nothing else this month, make a few calls to your cable, Internet and phone provider.
 
Not sure on the exact dollar amount but im pretty close!.

Well actually Im there since we dont have a mortgage payment now, but thats kinda cheating and will change rather soon
 
Brittany and I were talking about something similar today. We were basically saying we can live off one of our paychecks, and put the other 100 percent towards paying off our house as quickly as possible.
 
I followed this for a while and it was pretty interesting. Now obviously everybody's financial situation is different, but do you think you could cut your budget dramatically each month?

http://finance.yahoo.com/news/could-cut-spending-1-000-145150037.html

As a newspaper columnist in Detroit, Brian J. O'Connor didn't feel like he had much job security. "My paper had been sold, which automatically makes everybody nervous, and clearly Detroit was not doing well," O'Connor says of the bleak period in October 2009 when he launched his money-saving experiment.

That experiment involved cutting $1,000 a month from his budget, largely by focusing on recurring expenses. "Partly I wanted to fail as much as succeed because I wanted to illustrate how tough it can be if you really have to make big cuts in a family budget," O'Connor, 53, says. If parents went to work in the morning and came home unemployed, or suddenly lost overtime pay - as many workers did in Detroit during the recession - then they similarly needed to immediately transform their spending in order to stay afloat, he says.

His series of humorous columns on the experiment were so popular that he turned them into a book, "The $1,000 Challenge: How One Family Slashed Its Budget Without Moving Under a Bridge or Living on Government Cheese," which will be released this week.

Trimming $1,000 a month, which he managed to do, might sound overly ambitious, but O'Connor says that's the point. "It had to be a high-wire act, or there'd be nothing at stake," he says, adding that even cutting a grand each month wouldn't be enough for him, his wife and his son to survive if he suddenly lost his job. Still, it would be a start.

Ready to replicate O'Connor's strategy? Here are five categories where you're most likely to gin up some serious savings.

1. Phone, cable and Internet
"The easiest savings I got was cutting the utilities," O'Connor says. After spending an afternoon making a handful of calls to his cable, phone and Internet provider, he slimmed down his bundle of charges by about $140 per month. Part of that was removing services he didn't need, such as a $15 monthly charge that allowed him to use his cellphone as a modem (he forgot to cancel that service after a vacation), and a third-party voice messaging service on his home phone.

He trimmed down his cable service to a 200 channel package, which generated about $30 in savings. When he similarly downgraded his Internet service based on the amount of data his family actually used, the provider rebated him for the previous two months, since he had been paying for a more expensive data plan than he needed.

The total savings came to $140 a month plus $653.80 in refunds, temporary discounts and a $200 gift card. "That's more than a month's worth of groceries plus ongoing savings for just a couple hours on the phone," O'Connor says.

"Some of it was just dumb, which is a recurring theme in the book," O'Connor says. In other words, if he had paid attention to his bills, he would have had the charges removed long ago. But it's easy to never get around to it, or to overlook those superfluous expenses. That's why O'Connor recommends taking a close look at every household bill once a month, so you can eliminate the services you don't even realize you're paying for.

2. Unusual expenses
Do you have an oddball expense that's eating away at your bank account each month? For some people, it might be an expensive hobby; for O'Connor, it was his 30-year-old boat. It was costing him several hundred dollars in repairs some months. He saved almost $100 a month by creating a separate annual fund that served as a cushion for boat-related expenses, instead of scrambling to come up with the money whenever something broke.

3. Child care
If your employer offers flexible spending accounts, you can set aside pre-tax dollars to pay for health care, child care and commuting costs, up to certain limits. O'Connor saved more than $100 a month by paying for his son's speech therapy through a flexible health spending account. He points out that for two working parents, taking advantage of child care flexible spending accounts can also make a big dent in monthly expenses.

4. Home
Refinancing when interest rates are low can help reduce monthly mortgage payments. When O'Connor refinanced, he opted to slightly increase his monthly payment so he could switch to a 15-year mortgage and make sure his home was paid off prior to retirement. For monthly savings, O'Connor drilled into his home maintenance spending. He cut $60 a month by stopping maid service and an extra $10 from regular home maintenance.

5. Groceries
Food shopping is an area ripe for savings, since it's easy to overspend on name-brand pasta sauce, organic apples and prepared meals. O'Connor invested some time into comparison shopping and coupon hunting - on his first trip under his new regime, he spent 2.5 hours at the grocery store -- but it paid off. "You spend 10 minutes walking up and down the frozen meat aisle looking for the special on frozen turkey breast," he says.

Subsequent trips, though, did not take nearly as long because he developed his system (and gained familiarity with the store's placements). He saved about $40 for the month, and he didn't feel like he was sacrificing much. "Store-brand tomatoes don't feel any different to me than premium," he says.

Still, it's hard to spend the time to maximize deals every week, O'Connor acknowledges, especially with two working parents. He and his wife have to skip their coupon-maximizing efforts some weeks, especially when one of them is traveling for work.

The biggest takeaway from O'Connor's $1,000 challenge is to focus on recurring expenses, because when you cut them once, you keep them off the books the following months, too. So if you do nothing else this month, make a few calls to your cable, Internet and phone provider.

That's nuts I wonder how much I could cut makes me wonder quite a bit. I know personal spending kills me every month.
 
Interesting read, and something I need to do again.

I got pretty close to this back in March, simply by changing the vehicle I drive.
 
That's nuts I wonder how much I could cut makes me wonder quite a bit. I know personal spending kills me every month.
I got an easy way for you to cut $1000/month Buck, here it is;

Dont buy a putter.
 
  • Thread starter
  • Admin
  • #7
Brittany and I were talking about something similar today. We were basically saying we can live off one of our paychecks, and put the other 100 percent towards paying off our house as quickly as possible.

That's nuts I wonder how much I could cut makes me wonder quite a bit. I know personal spending kills me every month.

I think as generations pass, less and less attention is paid to retirement planning sadly.
 
Interesting read, and something I need to do again.

I got pretty close to this back in March, simply by changing the vehicle I drive.

I was thinking about that as well but I think I'm more than halfway having my Acura paid off. Then I'll be saving a lot of cash.
 
Our biggest cuts were:

1. Reducing the amount of eating out we do.
2. Reducing the unnecessary spending on non essentials
3. Cutting back on the tv package we had and getting prices lowered in other areas.

For awhile we tracking every single nickle spent and compared it to what I budgeted for the month in every area and made changes accordingly.
 
I think as generations pass, less and less attention is paid to retirement planning sadly.

I have a pension from the police dept even if I'm barely vested a pension from my current job when I retire and I started a 457 when I got hired here so that will have 25+ years of investments when I go. I hope that's enough it I still worry
 
We could do it but it would require tightening the belt quite a few notches, not sure if it would be something we could sustain long term. I am always reminding my wife that money doesn't grow on trees.
 
I have a pension from the police dept even if I'm barely vested a pension from my current job when I retire and I started a 457 when I got hired here so that will have 25+ years of investments when I go. I hope that's enough it I still worry

I think you are more the exception as we hear so many that do so little.
 
I think as generations pass, less and less attention is paid to retirement planning sadly.

I agree
 
Refinancing is a big one and saved us a ton of money this year. And with a second child coming, child care costs are gonna sky rocket for us next year (they go back down after their first birthday), so the flex account will be huge there.

Unfortunately, I would be able to get pretty close to this goal if I didn't renew my club membership, but I'm not sure I'm wiling to do that yet. It would essentially mean I would golf 75% less.
 
Im certain the world will end before I retire so not really planning for the future
 
This is interesting. I've thought about this before and did the cable thing and then some.
My wife and I actually agreed to get rid of cable altogether and saved over $100 a month. We got a good HD Antennae and stream a lot.
I know I could save a good chunk if I brought lunch to work more instead of buying it.
Every degree you lower the thermostat decreases your gas bill by 3% too.
It would be fun and worthwhile to pay even more attention to this idea.
 
This is interesting. I've thought about this before and did the cable thing and then some.
My wife and I actually agreed to get rid of cable altogether and saved over $100 a month. We got a good HD Antennae and stream a lot.
I know I could save a good chunk if I brought lunch to work more instead of buying it.
Every degree you lower the thermostat decreases your gas bill by 3% too.
It would be fun and worthwhile to pay even more attention to this idea.

I really should think about dropping cable, but I'm just not ready yet. I will never push the temperature up on the AC, that is non negotiable.
 
The one thing that I can't believe is that we have a matching 401k program at work where you have to contribute 5% so they will match your 5% and we have numerous people that don't do it. Just flat out refusing to take "free" money.
 
Interesting read and provoked thoughts. I am 100% sure we couldn't cut 1000 out of our budget though. Both being supply teachers, we don't work July/August at all, and rarely in June/Sept, so we have to save as much as possible over the year and know our budget really well (our monthly expenses are ~3500, so 1000 would be a huge change). We don't really have cell phones (we share a $100 a year pay as you go for emergencies or necessary meetings), get only basic cable (well, satellite), the cheapest high speed internet (though we do spend 5 extra bucks a month to get 100gb bandwidth), only use A/C on days over 30° (90+ fake degrees), have 2 efficient space heaters for living room and bedroom, and only one is on at a time. We re-did my student loan to extend my pay period over an extra 9 years to get my payments from 600 to 150 a month, so can't do that again. Got a 7 year interest free loan for our Elantra. Our typical monthly discretionary spending is probably about 500. We could cut that right down, but that would mean no golf, no movies, no dinners out, no new clothing, no visiting friends and family, etc. If we really put in effort and rarely did anything recreation wise we could probably cut 200 out of our monthly budget. Luckily, my wife is very frugal and I've been paying my own way for things since I was 14 so am good at not wasting money. On the other hand, I know at least 3 people who could easily cut 2k from their expenses and notice little difference. All depends on income and perceived solvency I guess.
 
Stop going to Starbucks? I retired ten months ago so we have been more aware of expenses being on a "fixed income". I am much more aware of what things cost and when something costs more. Fortunately, a good career and reasonable retirement planning have allowed us to continue the same lifestyle (including 137 rounds of golf since Jan 1).
 
Couldn't cut 1k. Have already trimmed most fat. Could cut a number of non-necessities if we had to but it would probably only be around $300-500 at most.

But no bad debt (house, one car pmt). Building up the emergency fund. Will start maxing out 401k next year.

I'd love to play more gold or buy new clubs every year but I try to be "good". It will help when the 2yr old is out of diapers and out of daycare ($10k per year !?!?!?)


Gently tapped like a downhill three-footer.
 
An interesting challenge, but I kind of feel like I must be the exception since I'm already doing most of those things. Since my wife started staying home when our son was born, that really put pressure on the checking account and we started cutting back and tracking everything. Our biggest expense is groceries, and that's primarily because we try to eat somewhat healthy, and healthy food is a lot more expensive than junk pre-processed crap.
 
I think as generations pass, less and less attention is paid to retirement planning sadly.
It is sad and ironic because every generation going forward needs to be extra personally diligent about retirement. Sadly, SS just isn't going to fully be there (projected shortfall happens to coincide with the exact year I'm scheduled to retire. Yippee!) so if we don't take care of it ourselves were scr#wed.
 
Hmm, interesting and wonder why more people don't do this. My wife and I max out our 401k and IRA, have a 15yr mortgage and still have ample savings per month. Partly blame our education system. It really doesn't prepare kids for the real world. Good thing I had good parents.
 
No way I could cut 1,000 right now out of our budget as we have zero car payments, no cable/satelite, rarely eat out, have internet through the phone line(cheap). The only place we could cut money is getting rid of my internet on my phone, I could cut out beer or whiskey(honestly not much), give up golf(not happening), quit giving to charity(not happening), I could buy into the mess fund at work which would save me money on food at work(not as healthy as what I currently eat). we already heat with wood pellets instead of propane which saves us an easy 600-700 a month, have AC only when I put in the window unit into our bedroom when temps don't drop into the 60's at night. We grow a garden and can lots of food or freeze it, have chickens for eggs and sell what we don't eat to pay for feed(our eggs are free).

At most we could save 300-400 maybe and I don't think it would be that high. We live off a little more than one income as the wife pays for the house groceries and her gas and I can still save some change for golf stuff.
 
Back
Top