Is Tyreek Hill a HOFer?
Not yet. HOF talent, but needs to build that resume up more.
Too early to say. He is an unique talent and top WR today, but I think he has more to prove to become a HOFer.
- Admin
- #4
I say yes.
3 x All Pro
6 x Pro Bowler
I believe Calvin Johnson got in with similar.
3 x All Pro
6 x Pro Bowler
I believe Calvin Johnson got in with similar.
I think he is on the PATH of a HOFer, but if he stopped playing today, he wouldn't be one.
If he keeps doing what he has been doing (not more not less) he is though.
He would need to fall off to fall out of the runnings in my opinion.
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2018
- Messages
- 33,188
- Reaction score
- 47,404
- Location
- Oxford, Mississippi
- Handicap
- 10.4
He's getting there. Keep doing what he's doing and he'll be in.
I think he's on his way. I just wonder if going to the Dolphins will hurt his chances. Sorry GG.
Not yet. On the way, but he still has a ways to go so let's see what happens, especially since now he's playing with "the most accurate QB ever"...
I think he is on his way to being a HOF'er, also think this year will go a long ways towards making that argument for him as the Chiefs fall off some without him, and the Dolphins and Tua look better.
- Admin
- #16
Yeah its a huge number and when you look back through guys that have that it says a lot. Megatron had that in his entire career I believe.
No. He’s short of Sterling Sharpe’s numbers and that’s my argument.
gonyr
Well-known member
Not yet, but definitely if his career continues at its current trajectory
Let’s see how he does with his new team/quarterback!
The comps to Megatron are interesting. I feel like he had games that he simply took over and willed his team to win. Not sure Hill has quite that level of dominance.
that said, I think he is well on his way.
that said, I think he is well on his way.
- Staff
- #21
yup, first-team AP is way more impressive than pro bowls. I actually didn't realize he had that many. When I see that and then use the eyeball test for just how much of a game breaker he has been and still could be, he's bound to get in, and I'd say would likely get in if he retired now.
- Admin
- #22
Man, the Bucs D thinks otherwise hahaha. I think he had 200 yards in a half against them.
No. Not yet. Calvin Johnson was unguardable and the best WR in the game every year he played on a team that couldn’t run the ball!
I think he'll have less competition overall. I know the QB isn't as widely known but his speed and ability to get open could get him some good openings.
I did look it up but they are also playing easier opponents this year than the Chiefs so maybe all of that could be a boon for him?
He'll go quick in fantasy once we get to WR's - that is a litmus test for me on HOF ability as well. I just think he'll be good with the move.